Are Tariffs Here to Stay? Wharton Professor Breaks Down U.S. Trade Policy

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Howard Butcher III Professor of Finance Joao Gomes breaks down the Trump administration's tariff strategy, discussing economic theory, trade deficits, and the global impact of aggressive trade policies. The conversation explores the strategic use of uncertainty, corporate response, and the long-term outlook for tariffs in U.S. policy.

#Tariffs #TradePolicy #GlobalEconomy #TradeWar ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. understanding the tariff plans of President Trump and his administration is a challenge for many
  2. people and many companies to try and better understand it a pleasure to be joined here in
  3. studio by Jo Gomesh who is a finance professor and senior vice dean of research centers and
  4. academic initiatives here at the Wharton School jo great to see you again how are you good to see you
  5. Dan thanks for having me okay so we're a while into this now how have you viewed I guess the
  6. process that we have seen play out the process you said hard to understand and I think I think
  7. purposefully hard to understand so the process is gamesmanship no question i I've been trying
  8. to focus on what's the end game and trying to understand where we're going to land and struggle
  9. with that to be honest um the process without question is to create confusion to play a game
  10. where and and and there's really good economic theory I have to say behind it saying that you
  11. know if if if we're playing these kinds of games and your adversary doesn't know what you're going
  12. to do and is actually frankly nervous of of the outcomes this is actually a very good strategy so
  13. I I I can't blame the president for thinking this way it's it's maybe a little you know one of those
  14. examples where a little knowledge is a little more worrisome than than having a lot of knowledge but
  15. but there's a lot of good theory for this and and and the president is also right i will give him
  16. credit in saying that other countries have a lot of non-tariff barriers against us the Europeans do
  17. a lot of countries in Asia do and and and again a lot of economic theory would say going back 50 or
  18. 60 years that if countries do not have free trade it's not necessarily optimal for you to have free
  19. trade and and you should think through that and and and I think as a result you can't look at
  20. this and say this is totally doesn't make sense you make there's lots of arguments why it makes
  21. sense having said that I don't think the trade deficit is a big problem for us i I I think it's
  22. an obsession not a problem um but the reality is tariffs are here to stay i think it's a question
  23. of how how large against whom and and for how long but they're probably here to stay all right so
  24. you mentioned the trade deficit which obviously draws a lot of attention a lot of people would
  25. say there's an element of having a trade deficit which is actually a good thing when you're doing
  26. international trade but I guess the question is where is that level of you know not having too
  27. much or or too little it's a really good question and clearly context matters the context here is
  28. this is the USA we have the reserve currency uh a trade deficit is much less of concern for
  29. us and and is the result of a lot of corporate optimization of supply chains to a large extent
  30. you know Apple has its iPhones manufactured elsewhere they could have had them done here
  31. they don't want to because it's not efficient it's not profitable it's not the best way to supply
  32. the cheapest possible product or the best possible product for American consumers and world consumers
  33. the trade for us I don't see it as a problem it is an obsession it is unfortunate that my profession
  34. economists have not been able to explain to people that the trade deficit is not a major priority
  35. and a major concern it's not the reason why some people are struggling in the US it's been on net
  36. a positive thing um but clearly has attracted a lot of negative publicity and we're dealing
  37. with trying to cure what it's not a disease what's more what's the most likely outcome then because I
  38. think some people are already saying that if there is a level of tariff that the United States is
  39. putting on other countries that maybe it brings the other countries back closer to where we are
  40. and maybe that kind of eases the the the feelings amongst everybody yes that's the main thing I'm
  41. struggling with what is the objective of this president and the people close to him i'm actually
  42. not sure and I'm not sure and as a result I don't know what the end game is one objective could be
  43. we impose tariffs the dollar appreciates we still have a trade deficit but we effectively maybe
  44. the other countries pay a lot of revenue to our treasury and and you know it could be $200 billion
  45. $300 billion um that could be a great objective to have um we don't have to raise taxes elsewhere
  46. um that would that's a sensible thing from our point of view and be great for the rest of the
  47. world but but that's a defensible thing another one is to say "No I want I don't want to depend
  48. quote unquote on the rest of the world and I want imports to go down." Right if you want imports to
  49. go down then you you are dependent on these goods being made in the US and and it's I think it's
  50. a belief of this of this presidency that doing business in the US is incredibly desirable our
  51. institutions are fantastic we we we have a really good governance we have really good markets so
  52. people will come here you know if if we can't make cars in Germany or Japan and send them here we'll
  53. just build more plants in the US the jobs will come i think it's a belief i'm not sure the data
  54. will support that um we may have to find out i I hope not because I don't think it's true in terms
  55. of the use of tariffs there's also conversation about going back in time to the days of Smoot
  56. Holly because the times are so different is there any way you can correlate what we saw back then
  57. and make it similar to what we're seeing right now i've been very very skeptical and and and and
  58. frankly also critical of my colleagues that have tried to do that and and I I think I I I think
  59. there's good reasons to be skeptical terrorists are a good thing there's real issues with them i
  60. I don't see any particular advantage other than raising tax revenues which is an interesting
  61. objective the president hasn't really talked much about uh but a comparisons with a hundred
  62. years ago when we were a very different economy and and we were in the middle of a depression we
  63. had the gold standard uh it's just so different i think very little can be learned from that i
  64. think it's a it's a useful scare tactic if you but it's I think it's a really bad analogy and
  65. and I think the other thing that a lot of people are starting to talk about is the uncertainty that
  66. it brings just in general we've obviously talked a lot about how the markets don't like uncertainty
  67. this is that next level of uncertainty kind of coming into the economy as a whole absolutely
  68. and I think this is the one thing that probably blindsided the president and his adviserss i
  69. think the sense that uncertainty is good from a from a negotiation standpoint but it has created
  70. a lot of damage to the US economy there's no question businesses are paralyzed corporate
  71. spending consumers importers uh we're waiting to see i mean what's the point of importing something
  72. right now from China if the tariffs are 145% today and maybe 10% in 6 months i would just wait so
  73. I think there's paralyzed markets and and that's done real damage to the economy we have to be seen
  74. how big how important then do the the role that the CEOs of companies here in the United States
  75. play in terms of having those conversations with the president about maybe things that they should
  76. look to tweak and the auto industry is obviously a huge right now yeah i I think I think absolutely
  77. I think that's the crucial role I would say absolutely crucial role and and I and I wish
  78. more of the people close to the president would be would be listening to that and listening what's
  79. happening in small businesses all around the US um absolutely crucial yes all right so take out the
  80. crystal ball if you'd like for a moment or two yes and what are your expectations on what you think
  81. we might see play out here over the next several months several months i don't know okay i think I
  82. know I think I think I No no i I think I feel more comfortable thinking 18 to two years 18 months to
  83. two years i think the endgame is some tariffs are here to stay i think they are addictive
  84. they're also addictive for every country in the world the truth is governments need revenues and
  85. once you see the amount of revenue the tariffs bring I think Democrats will be as addicted to
  86. them as Republicans are or are likely to be so the tariffs are here to stay in some form 5% 10% um
  87. across the board targeted I don't know but tariffs are definitely not a thing of the past not a thing
  88. of the moment uh now this uh fever of I'll put a bigger tariff on you than me and and this sort of
  89. sense of I I need to strike a deal not strike a deal i don't know how that plays out uh over
  90. the next six months but I'm fairly comfortable we're going to be here two three years out and
  91. we'll have tariff we'll have a different regime where there's going to be more higher tariffs
  92. around the world there'll be some nice trade deals possibly with some of the countries that are more
  93. desperate to do business with us i think India is a really important um case in point there um
  94. so I I am generally optimistic that the worse is over i think it was a useful lesson in how not
  95. to provoke the gods the market gods um so I I'm I'm genuinely optimistic about that but I think
  96. we're in for six months of uncertainty jah great to talk to you again thanks very much thank you
  97. Dan thank you gomez who is senior vice dean and professor of finance here at the Wharton School

Brief Summary

Jo Gomesh discusses Trump's tariffs, trade deficits, and their market impacts, predicting tariffs will persist and create ongoing uncertainty.

Key points

  • Understanding Tariffs. Understanding the tariff plans of President Trump is a challenge for many.
  • The Purpose of Confusion. The process behind tariffs is seen as intentionally confusing.
  • Trade Deficit Perspective. The trade deficit is viewed as an obsession rather than a problem.
  • Optimism Amid Uncertainty. Despite challenges, there is optimism about the future of trade and tariffs.
  • Tariffs' Future. Expect tariffs to remain in some form for the foreseeable future.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes