Linking Commerce to Geopolitics: The Candidates' Views on Gl

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

With global financial markets in turmoil, trade will most likely be an urgent concern for the next president. As part of Knowledge@Wharton's ongoing coverage of the upcoming November election, we examine the candidates' views on trade issues. So far, both Republican John McCain and Democrat Barack Obama have tended to follow predictable party lines: McCain is a supporter of free trade and would back additional multilateral trade pacts, while Obama urges a reexamination of trade agreements and their effect on the environment and U.S. workers. πŸ“‚ Public Policy

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. this podcast is brought to you by knowledge at Warton please visit knowledge. won. up.edu for more
  2. information there's two ways to answer that question the first is based on their explicit references to trade
  3. policy um McCain obvious viously has um a far more active and uh pro- international trade international
  4. relations U policy explicitly um he has not only uh endorsed the United States current um trade
  5. obligations but he has uh explicitly spoken of how trade regulations can be used to further the US agenda or in some
  6. sense is the world's agenda uh Barack Obama has explicitly threatened to withdraw from NAFTA um he's used that as
  7. a threat to bring Canadian and Mexican negotiators to the table um he has referred to NAFTA as a
  8. flawed agreement uh meaning flawed in that um not meaning flaw in that it encompasses too much trade and too open
  9. trade actually meaning meaning that it does do that not necessarily meaning that uh some people think of it as
  10. flawed because it inhibits trade a little bit he's the opposite he says it doesn't inhibit it enough um he has
  11. criticized a number of the bilateral uh negotiations that the US has entered into or has concluded so you know his
  12. explicit position would seem to be um not endorsing or not supporting or not promoting
  13. international trade but if you look at their non trade positions and if you look at in
  14. particular their advisers um and the people who who they talk to um um John McCain would seem to
  15. be continuing the um somewhat um realist old school Cold War trade policies and Barack
  16. Obama his language and his advisers represent a change but I should say possible change
  17. from that and and in the context of trade you know you know that might open up some interesting opportunities or
  18. some differences so you you have to look both at their explicit language in which
  19. John uh John McCain is clearly the more trade friendly candidate and their underlying positions in which Barack
  20. Obama represents the greater possibility of of um fitting into the new world he hasn't explicitly backed off of his
  21. condemnation of NAFTA the the negative things he said about NAFTA but your your Point's an interesting
  22. point um you know arguably he was just uh saying the things that a Democratic candidate has to
  23. say um yeah I I I I I would want to be careful in reading too much into that interpret
  24. I mean he said what he said and and and to me the the the the most troubling thing is that he explicitly threatened
  25. to withdraw from NAFTA and he explicitly used it as a threat um to bring Canadian and Mexican
  26. nego Table and the United States has had a long period you know recent period of
  27. of being a really bad neighbor to Mexico and Canada and we don't need to be threatening them that's that even as a
  28. campaign measure that that that that should be troubling to anyone who's interested in
  29. meaningful International uh relationships commercial relationships there's the good and the
  30. Bad and the Ugly for that matter you know the the good is uh unlike um some people who can't move past the Cold
  31. War when I say can I don't mean that they're somehow congenitally incapable of thought I mean just it's the way they
  32. were brought up in the system and it's their way of seeing the world and that's an awfully difficult thing to change if
  33. it changes possible at all so I don't mean it pejoratively but unlike some people who come at the world from that
  34. position um John McCain has on occasion spoken of trade as a as a tool for accomplishing good things
  35. uh good power objectives and the one that comes to mind obviously is um that opening up broader trade relationships
  36. with discret countries in the Middle East would um further US policies in the Middle East which is probably if not
  37. absolutely true it would also and this is not that relevant to people who think this way but it would also open up a lot
  38. of other great things accomplish a lot of other great things so that's that's the good um the bad and then you know
  39. the bad is when um in in a world in which relationships are being created in new
  40. and unique uh not so much unique but I guess unique in the context of the Cold War um but new and exciting and and all
  41. kinds of different ways um you know the Cold War thinking locks you into seeing relationships
  42. black and white and seeing relationships as furthering this objective or furthering the enemy's objective and and
  43. and that inhibits a lot of creativity a lot of potential opportunities for business people not necessarily only us
  44. business people but certainly including us business people um you know the world is just
  45. reshaping itself and seeing it this particular way may not be the most fruitful the ugly is what we've been
  46. seeing over the last few years the United States stes is quite possibly in in the category of you know
  47. most despised Nations um we have put ourselves in the in a position where people don't want
  48. interact with us you I've walked down streets and people have said we won't buy clothes from the United States
  49. because we don't want to we don't even want to that much affiliation with the United States um there's a there's a
  50. really ugly uh part and it does blow back in thinking of the world in terms of enemies and and that are of this
  51. particular ilk and um it's a life or death struggle I'm talking about the Cold War I'm not talking about any other
  52. particular War the Cold War probably was right but it's over and um it's it's ugly to keep tarring people with that
  53. particular bre Rush sadly it doesn't seem to be affecting either of them because you're
  54. your your question gets at a really pertinent issue the the position of the United States in the world um is just by
  55. the fact that the world is changing changing and the candidates keep talking about trade using just the same old
  56. tired rhetoric um they're not addressing really fundamental shifts in how the world is put
  57. together and you know part of it is if you step out there and and talk about these shifts it's really easy as a
  58. political matter to just say you know he's unpatriotic or she's unpatriotic and and and and and turn it into you
  59. know nonsense um we we're not having a real discussion about these really important
  60. you know things that are going to happen in the future and how the United States
  61. needs to position itself now as a political matter and how businesses need to be supported in positioning
  62. themselves as a relationship matter an economic or commercial matter just not getting that
  63. discussion I had the The Good Fortune to hear uh a gentleman um in in from Hong Kong and China
  64. addressing a a a a group of primarily Asian um people in maau and he he put it pretty succinctly
  65. he said you know for a long time the world has been structured like this and um the the there's a a narrow
  66. group of people who are basically uh enjoying the benefit provided by a lot of people cheap labor
  67. cheap Commodities um um you know large amounts of capital that all flow up to them who get to use
  68. it uh development is not a zero sum game development doesn't create this um development doesn't create a
  69. situation in which these people are replaced by China is a stereotype and probably a bad one but everyone knows
  70. China it creates a situation in which the people from here move up and so there are a few of them so it creates this
  71. right now um there's going to be more people who are able to consume more stuff Services Goods whatever just stuff
  72. um there's going to be more people who demand more stuff there's going to be more competition over the basic input
  73. put primarily Commodities there certainly will be more competition for cheap labor because there's not going to
  74. be much of that left right um that that this is not you know something that we can argue
  75. about like climate change the rest of the world isn't arguing about but we are this isn't something that we can you
  76. know say it ain't gonna happen this is inevitable the world develops and it's not Zero
  77. Sum so if you're worried about losing your job you should be um if you're worried about
  78. fundamental shifts in the way the world is put together that that that are going
  79. to affect you you should be that that that doesn't mean that the answer is the United States removes itself from this
  80. it can't it it it it is virtually impossible North Korea is trying and it isn't working out too well for them and
  81. so you know we need to get past the whole um you know turning it into a scare issue that can get some people
  82. elected so they can skim some money and do whatever the hell they do we need for
  83. the worker and the supplier and the then the buyer of Commodities who's now going to
  84. be competing with most of the world we need them to sit down and say this is where I am this is where it looks like
  85. the world is headed how do I get where I want to be and then how do you the government helped me get there because
  86. the the the the this the usual response you know we're not going to export jobs or my opponent blah blah blah that's not
  87. going to get us anywhere this is going to happen and if the worker who's worried about losing her job if you know
  88. if all everyone else doesn't understand this that's that's a surprisingly complicated
  89. question political borders mean a lot I'm certainly not here to say that there's you know one world now now but
  90. but they're they're they're becoming more and more permeable and and and and to ignore that
  91. fact is not being patriotic it's being silly um but but they do matter they do matter so
  92. there there are things that can be done in the short run to um to I don't protect is a good word to
  93. build a wall and a castle and and isolate yourself from what's going on in the world but but it's it's it it
  94. is it is almost of necessity only temporary and so you know you're basically saying do you manage the
  95. situation now or do you manage the situation later and that's how you should be looking at it is managing the
  96. situation you shouldn't be looking at as how do I prevent this from ever happening you know it's happening in the
  97. rest of the world um the United States either either manages how it it interacts with the
  98. rest of the world or the United States gets managed and again you know that's going
  99. to be called unpatriotic and United States this United States that but I can't think of a good business person
  100. out there who would say no you don't manage situations you know this is what's happening manage it um
  101. protectionism yeah it may buy you some votes for a while and yeah it may it may misallocate some money for a while
  102. because protectionism always involves losers um you know there's always someone who loses from that but in in in
  103. the long run you know you know it it it can't it can't Shield us from the change
  104. and I I Ed the word change instead of hurt because if it's managed at all but particularly if it's
  105. managed well it's a great thing you know it's a wonderful thing there's abundant
  106. opportunities in in the way the world is moving well um no obviously not uh and and one you know one interesting
  107. thing about this is um eventually you know the US Labor will be as competitive if
  108. not more competitive than it has been in the past you know we're going through an
  109. interesting period now but if you look at China um and I hate to always use China it's it's kind of lazy but
  110. everybody does and and there's a lot of numbers out there and stuff if you look at China the the cost of Labor in China
  111. has risen to the point where a lot of factories in China are are moving shutting down um you know China is not
  112. like the only place in the world that's ever going to develop um it's going to happen
  113. elsewhere and eventually there's going to be more consumers in China than there are labors in fact um they're looking at
  114. I think 2019 is the date when that magical event occurs um you know the us through smart
  115. application of of uh technology and smart application of management techniques and with changing costs of
  116. transportation and and all kinds of things um you know us labor has a place a great place in the changing World on
  117. the other hand if US Labor just and and and and other aspects of the US just hides behind you know let's keep things
  118. the way they always were and not so much you know the way things always were we almost always referring to the
  119. 1950s when most of the other industrialized nations had been bombed back to the Stone Age in World War II
  120. that ain't happening no matter how many walls we put up um that a't happening but you know so
  121. no we can't retrain US Labor the entirety of it we don't need to we need to just think we to talk about it in
  122. different ways which isn't happening right now it's again their explicit language I
  123. would give a slight Edge to um McCain John McCain uh with his um more creative use
  124. of trade to uh as a diplomatic tool um but the underlying positions um they they don't they don't
  125. talk about it explicitly but you know the McCain's advisers are more of the same um it's it's hard
  126. to picture them thinking about this creatively as as business people would uh it's it's easier to think of them
  127. thinking of this in the same old political way for more information please visit
  128. knowledge. won. up.edu you

Brief Summary

McCain and Obama have contrasting views on trade policy, particularly regarding NAFTA and international relations.

Key points

  • The Changing World of Trade. The discussion around trade is evolving, but political rhetoric remains stagnant. 'The world is changing, and the candidates keep talking about trade using the same old rhetoric.'
  • Opportunities in Development. Development is a positive force that creates opportunities rather than taking them away. 'Development is not a zero-sum game; it creates opportunities for everyone.'
  • Managing Global Interactions. The US must adapt to global changes rather than retreating into isolation. 'We need to manage how we interact with the rest of the world, not isolate ourselves.'
  • The Risks of Protectionism. Protectionism might seem beneficial in the short term, but it has long-term consequences. 'Protectionism may buy you some votes for a while, but it always involves losers.'
  • Future Competitiveness of US Labor. US Labor has the potential to be highly competitive in the future. 'The US Labor will be as competitive, if not more competitive, than it has been in the past.'

Episode highlights

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes