Can We Fix Retirement Inequality?

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

EPISODE OVERVIEW Wharton Professor and Penn Wharton Budget Model Faculty Director Kent Smetters discusses how automated retirement savings accounts could help low-income households build up to $200,000 in risk-adjusted savings, supplementing Social Security and promoting intergenerational wealth. He highlights the importance of making these accounts fully bequeathable and revenue-neutral by redirecting existing tax subsidies. This conversation explores solutions for closing the retirement savings gap and building financial security for underserved communities.

PODCAST OVERVIEW Every day, business scholars answer pressing questions in their research - but what do their insights mean for you? In this podcast, Wharton faculty dive into what inspired their studies and how their findings resonate with the world today. Learn how research insights translate into knowledge you can use, with host Dan Loney.

Learn more at http://whr.tn/rippleeffect.

#retirement #publicpolicy #economicpolicy #taxpolicy #financialinclusion ----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Kent Smetters: It's going to be— the Trust Fund is going to deplete with— within a decade. And so I think, you know, it's— there's
  2. partly that comfort, but also what we hear— heard from a lot of low-income households— over the last 20 years, when I was with
  3. the administration, the Bush Administration and then since, is that they want to leave something that's bequeathable to
  4. their heirs. And so we also especially heard this— coming from Black households, and the Black members, for example, of
  5. the Social Security Commission under President Bush, was that there's this great need for, you know, how do we create
  6. intergenerational wealth? And these types of accounts, they'll be fully bequeathable.
  7. Welcome to <i>The Ripple Effect</i>, the podcast that takes you on a journey through the minds of Wharton faculty. I'm your host, Dan
  8. Loney, and in each episode, we'll be diving deep into the inspiration behind the groundbreaking research that
  9. Wharton professors have conducted and exploring how their findings resonate with the world today.
  10. Well, one of the concerns around retirement savings is the gap between the haves and the have nots. So how do households who are considered
  11. to be in lower income brackets still secure that level of retirement finance that they're going to need? It's an area that
  12. has been looked at and focused on by the Penn Wharton Budget Model, and we are pleased to have their Faculty Director,
  13. Wharton Professor Kent Smetters, joining us here in studio. Great to see you, Kent. - Great to be back.
  14. Why is this component, though, so important when we think about retirement, especially to do the research that you've done on this?
  15. So, about half of households in the United States really don't have a lot of material savings toward retirement. Now, one
  16. could argue that could be actually optimal if you believe that Social Security benefits, Medicare benefits, and believe
  17. it or not, Medicaid, because that actually pays for the long term care component of in retirement— if you think that
  18. those are going to pay as scheduled. You know, not having a lot of saving may be okay for a lot of these households. But
  19. those programs are under a lot of pressure right now, and they are contributing to large shortfalls in our projected
  20. finances for the country. And it's always good to have your own nest egg as well. And so that— I think that's why— on one
  21. hand, things get embellished by some people that say that, you know, there's a huge, huge problem here. On the other hand, there
  22. is a problem, still. Some of it is caused by government policy itself, but there is a problem.
  23. And this is something that at least policymakers are aware of, or at least they want to get more information about so we
  24. know a potential path that we need to go down. -That's right, and in particular— so policymakers are certainly aware
  25. of— that a lot of the low-income households in their districts really are not saving that much for retirement, and that, you
  26. know, we ask, why is programs like Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid kind of the third rail of politics? It's partly
  27. because people have become so dependent on those programs, no one wants to touch them. But at the same time, there's no
  28. question going forward, we're gonna have to figure out another approach. - $200,000
  29. was the level that you used in the research. Take us through why that level is important in terms of determining that level
  30. of retirement savings that people would have. - Yeah. So the thought experiment was as
  31. follows. You know, people don't think we do, necessarily, a lot of direct subsidy for retirement income in the United States. In
  32. fact, we do. When you calculate your AGI, your adjustable gross income, the "A" component there doesn't get a
  33. lot of attention, but there's a big, big tax write-off there, and that's through the fact that you can put in your— your
  34. contributions to a traditional 401(k) and a— on a pre-tax, or as a post-tax for a Roth 401(k). Both are tax subsidies. And so
  35. we spend about, as a country, about one and a quarter trillion dollars over 10 years for that— that subsidy, the combination of
  36. that traditional and the Roth. And if we just said, okay, we know who's benefiting from that is typically higher-income
  37. people. We also know that it doesn't have a huge impact on how much they actually save for retirement. That's what the
  38. research seems to suggest. In nerdy language, they don't have a big elasticity response to the tax incentives there. And so if
  39. we took that money and we set up automated retirement accounts for our lower-income households. And the idea would be, we just
  40. simply use the current administration of the Earned Income Tax Credit. No more administration. The same—
  41. basically the same qualifications, the same rules, different phase outs in terms of all that, but essentially we do
  42. a 10% contribution of income. So it's not like freebies here. You still have to work and so forth. We could use that money to
  43. really boost up low-income household savings accounts. And if you're a younger person, 25 years old, and you're on one of
  44. these, you know, low-income paths, we could, over time, get you, on a risk-adjusted basis, close to around $200,000 of
  45. retirement income or retirement savings, that then can be annuitized or converted into some type of income. And that could
  46. then top up Social Security and things like that. And so the same budget costs could be redirected toward kind of lower
  47. income. And ultimately totally expand— since we know the high income are not going to cut back a lot in their saving. The low
  48. income now are going to have saving. The net saving in society is going to go up. - What do you think that does,
  49. then, to debt overall, when you have that component factored in to the mix of retirement savings?
  50. So what we try to do is construct it in a way that's roughly revenue-neutral over 10 years. And so the idea is that, you
  51. know, we have these different options, kind of small, medium and large, and different phase outs, different matching rates
  52. and so forth. And the phase outs are— you know, obviously we're not going to be subsidizing 10% of income for really high-income
  53. folks, but this is for lower income. And so the idea is that the medium one basically is revenue neutral over a 10-year
  54. period. And so the low is, you know, less than you actually will now make money as the government, save some revenue.
  55. And the high is, it costs you a little bit more than current revenue costs associated with the 401(k) and 403(b) type of
  56. deductions. Technically speaking, those are adjustments rather than deductions. And so as a result, you know, we can
  57. get low-income households a pretty nice nest egg. And that's not playing tricks with, like, crazy returns. This is on the risk-
  58. adjusted basis. - Is the belief that being able to reach that 200,000 plateau is
  59. something that can provide lower- income households not only that nest egg, but a level of comfort that maybe they haven't had in
  60. the past? - That's right. And there's a couple things that can happen with it. One is that, yes, Social Security is going to be there in
  61. some form. You know, exactly how big it will be and so forth— but still not— you know, Social Security doesn't even guarantee that
  62. you'll stay out of poverty in old age. And so it's possible that your— your benefit is not going to be that big, and so
  63. forth. And who knows what the future brings, given that it's going to be— the Trust Fund's gonna deplete with— within a decade.
  64. And so I think, you know, it's— there's partly that comfort. But also what we've heard— heard from a lot of low-income households
  65. over the last 20 years, when I was with the administration, the Bush Administration, then since, is that they want to leave
  66. something that's bequeathable to their heirs. And so we also especially heard this coming from Black households, and the
  67. Black members, for example, of the Social Security Commission under President Bush, was that there's this great need for, you
  68. know, how do we create intergenerational wealth? And these types of accounts, they will be fully bequeathable. In
  69. particular, on one hand, they're designed in a way that you can't tap into them before retirement, because you can't top them up.
  70. These are purely non- contribution. The government does the— does the full contribution. The idea there is
  71. that, therefore, there's no right for you to tap into these before retirement. They are truly retirement accounts. Other
  72. hand, they are fully bequeathable, unlike Social Security. You can't bequeath your feature Social Security benefit after
  73. you die. And so I think this idea of being able to build up intergenerational wealth, helping your kid buy a— put a down
  74. payment for a house, you know, I think that can create a lot of value for people.
  75. How do you think, then, that concept really tackles the larger issue of just being able to build up retirement savings, and to a
  76. degree, the understanding of how to go about doing that? Yeah, yeah. I mean, there's stuff in here that I think both
  77. sides of the political spectrum should really like. One is a much greater tilt toward low- income houses and building up
  78. wealth and so forth. On the other hand, if I were on the opposite side of the political spectrum, I would say, you know
  79. what? This also means a little less pressure on Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid. Some people view this as kind of
  80. camel's nose under the tent strategy. There's no tent there. But the point is, is that you know, why have half of the
  81. population rely so heavily on those sources of income, of— of Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid for long-term care
  82. when, you know, I think they're looking for some more independence. I think people's sense of their ability to rely
  83. on the government to deliver in the future, you know— especially where our federal debt is exploding right now. We are now
  84. making higher interest payments than military, we're spending on the military. That does not bode well in history for countries
  85. that do that. And so I think it is— given the great uncertainty going forward, this is kind of a more decentralized way of
  86. creating comfort. - So is this part way, a path to trying to get lower income households the concept of fully—
  87. fully-funded retirement savings programs? Well, it certainly can augment that. You know, could you— if you
  88. go into retirement— and all this is after adjusting for inflation as well. - Sure. Yeah. And so it's like $200,000
  89. in today's dollars. So could— you know, you live in retirement on $200,000? You probably could. It wouldn't be a super comfortable, you know,
  90. standard of living. So I think this is more of a top up of— for Social Security. But even if Social Security, over time, really
  91. focused on poverty relief, rather than just, you know, this kind of image of the pension- like type system— I mean, not—
  92. that could actually be done really slowly over time, so that people who are age 50 and above today, for example, are not
  93. impacted at all. But slowly change the retirement age, slowly change the benefit structure, so that it focuses
  94. much more on poverty relief and so forth. You could— you could save money there, but you could also make sure people stay out
  95. of poverty. But they're not going to have a great life, you know, just on Social Security. - Sure. Yeah.
  96. But this can actually give them a fuller retirement. And again, for a lot of low-income
  97. households, that— what they really care about is— and I don't think this gets enough attention, especially in the
  98. Black community, Hispanic communities, where we've heard this from, is they really want something that is that— the idea
  99. of bequeathing wealth to the next generation. That shouldn't just be the rich white people thing, that should be something
  100. that's universal. - What's the reaction that you get to this idea from the policymakers
  101. right now? - Yeah, you know, I was shocked. Some of the policymakers were like, more—
  102. they actually were really gung- ho about it. They thought this was really cool. On one hand, you know, right now they're all
  103. focused on, you know, extenders for Tax Cuts and Jobs Act and things like that. And— but none— nonetheless, the reaction from
  104. both sides has been positive. It'd be— people are often nervous about, you know, is there a hidden agenda here and so forth? And it's no. I
  105. mean, it's just a way of trying to secure more retirement. You know, from the industry, I've— we've gotten some feedback, and,
  106. you know, some of the industry trade groups, they always have to attack every idea out there. You know, because that's— that's
  107. how they rationalize their existence. But from the players, the industry players themselves, they've— they actually, you
  108. know, agree with the statement that higher-income people are not going to really reduce their retirement saving that much from
  109. losing this tax benefit from the 401(k) deduction. And low-income people that are— this is definitely gonna boost up
  110. retirement. So overall retirement saving should actually increase, and that's something that they can— they
  111. feel like they can really tap into and provide things like streams of income, annuities and so forth.
  112. Kent, great to see you again. Thanks very much. - Thanks for having me. Thank you. Kent Smetters, who is Faculty Director of the Penn
  113. Wharton Budget Model. - Thank you for listening to <i>The Ripple Effect</i>. We hope you found this episode informative and
  114. engaging. Don't forget to subscribe and leave us a review so that we can continue to bring you the best insight from the
  115. Wharton School.

Brief Summary

Kent Smetters discusses retirement savings gaps and solutions for low-income households, emphasizing intergenerational wealth creation.

Key points

  • Creating Intergenerational Wealth. Smetters explains the need for accounts that can be bequeathed to heirs.
  • The Ripple Effect Podcast Introduction. Join host Dan Loney as he explores groundbreaking research from Wharton faculty.
  • Retirement Savings Gap. Kent Smetters discusses the disparity in retirement savings among different income brackets.
  • Policymakers' Positive Reaction. Smetters shares that policymakers are supportive of new retirement savings ideas.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes