Clean Power Plan and Lower Electricity Costs

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

How Clean Power Plan rules could spark investment and efficiency. 📂 Public Policy 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. I'd like to welcome Mike abito and he is a professor of business economics and public policy here at Wharton and he's
  2. going to talk to us about the clean power plan which is a signature accomplishment I think the Obama
  3. administration administration would say and it's designed to limit these carbon dioxide emissions from fossil fuel
  4. plants such as oil fired fired coal-fired natural gas-fired and doing that by setting a price for those
  5. emissions and I think one of the big questions is how do you actually do that do you do that from a federal level or
  6. state level and there's lots of rules and all that that affect this but the question is are they efficient and and
  7. how much trouble does it cause it the producers and then ultimately the consumers who would from it would be
  8. reflected in prices so would you please talk about and he's written a paper on this of course that this is all based on
  9. and could you give us a summary of what your research is found okay first of all
  10. thanks for inviting me to talk about this paper so basically in this project what we look at is the clean power plan
  11. which is the landmark policy that for the dress off of the Obama administration to address co2 emissions
  12. and here in this project were zeroing in on this issue of although the clean power plan is a federal based based on
  13. the federal level law such as clean air act implementation of the clean power plan rule is actually at the state level
  14. so this fact that you know you have different jurisdictions coming up with different rules or coming up with
  15. different ways to implement the policy may actually create the inefficiencies are supposed to being able to you know
  16. coordinate everyone at the federal level so this is really what we're studying in
  17. this paper and what what were some of the conclusions what did you find as you looked into so what's interesting here
  18. is that with emissions so we're looking at the emissions coming from as you said
  19. coal fire power and so we focus on pjm the Pennsylvania New Jersey Maryland inter connection
  20. which is basically a grid that this that covers or a wholesale market that covers
  21. 13 states and so firms who own elect our plans they produce across these 13 states and then the electricity that
  22. they produce they sell it in a single market p.m. and then they get a single price and what we recognize is that
  23. although co2 emissions may be regulated at the state level so let's focus on PG am so there let's say there's a co2
  24. permit market for each state so there are 13 markets they can trade among each other that really sounds like a very
  25. inefficient scenario but when a firm who owns plants the same Pennsylvania and Delaware is thinking about you know
  26. where should I produce okay they're gonna think they're going to look at the co2 price in Pennsylvania and compare it
  27. with the co2 price in Delaware and somehow decide okay where should I produce based on d co co 2 prices so
  28. even though seemingly these are disconnected markets the fact that you know affirms who participate in the
  29. single market for electricity has to make decisions that they can to account the distribution of prices across states
  30. somehow implicitly coordinates these separate markets such that as we found in the research that we did such that it
  31. actually alleviates or mitigate some of the inefficiencies of these separate markets so a power company regardless of
  32. what state they reside in and what the rules are of that state can easily being part of this grid you're describing
  33. produce that electricity in one of the other states that's part of that exact race Zoe yeah and so it doesn't to
  34. them they're sort of indifferent to the regulation except an extent that they're
  35. going to produce it where it's the least cost exactly so suppose you have two plants producing christx exactly the
  36. same costs exactly the same the only difference is that co2 price in Pennsylvania is more expensive than or
  37. attire and in Delaware that of core I'm going to move my production to Delaware the problem with that is you're
  38. pretty much limited with how much you can reallocate out but because you know the reason why probably prices in
  39. Pennsylvania is more expensive is because a lot of production is being made in Pennsylvania so you have big
  40. plans in Pennsylvania as opposed to small plants in Delaware so it's like I can't really move majority of my output
  41. from Pennsylvania into Delaware because it's cheaper in Delaware so here what we
  42. identifies the main mechanism in the paper is actually investment and the fact that investment is the main
  43. mechanism has consequences in terms of you know what's going to happen to electricity prices you know because of
  44. how we design the policy mm-hmm and so so was this all to answer the question that we have these new rules they're
  45. they're imposing there there it's a big change it's a big restriction on companies and then maybe it was thought
  46. that it's cause evening even more ripples and problems because now it's got to go from the federal level to the
  47. state level and it's complicated and that's just churning up all this inefficiency you're talking about so it
  48. was the purpose of the paper to show that well in fact the way that the market is set up kind of bypasses all of
  49. us in a way it's it kind of has that message so I guess we're coming from the premise that having states coordinate
  50. and have a single market and agree on and have a concession consensus of how to design a single markets this
  51. difficult proposition I mean you could think about it with a bigger picture like imagine you know you wanna we're
  52. all hoping for a global co2 market right but you know in order to have that you have to have china the u.s. each of
  53. these countries actually agree on the details of this might take a while even forever what the point of the paper is
  54. that okay wait a minute we don't need to really aim for that you know we can actually the fact that you know somehow
  55. we're talking about co2 emissions but it's coming from certain activities are known as these activities are
  56. coordinated across these different ended Avengers are big enough coverage then yeah we can actually do something so I
  57. so that's interesting so it's it's kind of a hopeful message exactly that you can
  58. actually you can actually apply some restrictions that will help keep carbon out of the atmosphere and you you you
  59. don't need to have it coordinated international even across the u.s. and these these regions are already set up
  60. on grids that cooperate and coordinate because when one plant has a sudden demand and can't meet it they were
  61. there's a way that they can draw on from an area that's not using them so although in the project we're focusing
  62. on the peach averages ppm just so we Pennsylvania New Jersey Maryland right which is William the market the covers
  63. oh yes although we're focusing on that there are a bunch of regional markets in the US as you said they're actually
  64. still somehow internet interconnected yet and as we talk about building infrastructure which is something that
  65. both presidential candidates talked about and that we have a new president who presumably might file through and
  66. that some of that could be on the electrical grid which would be in different regions could be could more
  67. easily connect to each other and that would create an even greater level of efficiency is that we don't address that
  68. in the project but it's one of the things that is a part of what we plan to look at in the future okay so that's the
  69. kind of thing to look at in the future yet so what what surprised you when you started looking at this did you come to
  70. the conclusion that you thought you would or did or so we kind of the basic economics is is there we kind of
  71. understood the basic economics but what how far cuz so specifically we're looking at we or our primary focus was
  72. on electricity prices under state by state which is you know having separate markets versus regional we're over PGM
  73. there's a single market we were our hope we understood the economics but you know
  74. once you go into the data it might tell you something something else so we were hoping that you know at least these are
  75. very either the electricity prices under the state by state and region are very close in fact that's actually we found
  76. right what surprised us a lot is that um profits are actually end up to be better in the state by state as opposed
  77. to regional case and that was really in a way surprising to us and it's only recently that we actually understood
  78. what was happening what could you explain that right yeah because it's kind of counterintuitive in the sense
  79. that you know with the state by state it seems that the laws are more stringent yeah right as opposed to the regional
  80. case and the reason why you actually end up with higher profits with state by state is that I mean it I mean this is
  81. not a general thing but it just so happens that you know given how much it costs to invest what is your portfolio
  82. of plans and what kind of investments you can make the fact that you know widow with your current portfolio of
  83. plants you're barely making any money okay that's what we mean by you know basically the price that you're getting
  84. in the market is almost exactly equal to your cost okay and these plants once you
  85. introduce the cpp the cost is going to go up but demand for electricity is what you call at least in the short term is
  86. very inelastic in the sense that people are willing to pay you know almost any amount just to get that specific amount
  87. of electricity right so what's going to happen is that when costs go up prices are going to go up into the same
  88. proportion and people are willing to pay for that but that creates a very strong
  89. incentive to invest okay so once you invest and the fact that you're investing in technologies that are
  90. cleaner and actually more efficient that means that you know when you compare the
  91. existing plants cost versus the new investment the gap is like this but then because of stringent laws this is
  92. actually going to go up so the reward from investing is actually much higher so is that to say that that these
  93. increased regulations actually provide an incentive to modernize exactly so I mean I there at the end of the day at
  94. some point in time all of these coal plants are going to get retired before they're gonna verdes or not
  95. there's a number what to see I'm a stringent CPP or a state-by-state CPP does is it basically make it faster okay
  96. it's gonna give a really strong say it's up to retire exactly plan and in here the underlying assumption in our models
  97. is that firms are profit maximizing we're not coercing them to invest we're not forcing them to invest it's just
  98. that the reward from investing is actually much higher with the stricter law yeah and when you're producing
  99. electricity it's not like there's a thousand different markets you can go to your wired into your location exact
  100. you're not going overseas dated I'm going to Mars yours yeah you can't even store it makes ambulance once you
  101. produce it has to go oh that may change right we do well the batteries and so okay um so you said you you gave us one
  102. example of something you'll be looking at next what else will you be looking at so actually what's interesting is that
  103. so I I work with a bunch of co-authors um Oh in this paper um and I basically didn't sleep this morning i was watching
  104. the lecture then the moment that we got the results of election by my co-author email like what's gonna happen to the
  105. CPP IRA so a little bit of background so CPP right now although it was the clean
  106. power plan although it was the final rule was put in the in the Federal Register last year around August around
  107. October 2015 in February 2016 the Supreme Court actually put a stay on it so right now the the weather this clean
  108. power plan will actually push truth depends on several things one is who won the presidency right and which we know
  109. already by now and so what's gonna happen to the composition of the three Supreme Court what's going to happen to
  110. the EPA so one of my co-authors was pretty worried about okay what's gonna happen to the project because if there's
  111. no CPP then you know why are we talking about this but I think our project the fact that we're focusing on this
  112. separate markets different jurisdictions are supposed to you're a coordinated a way to regulate the emissions actually
  113. says something about this environment where we don't have CPP so that's something that our current project has
  114. something to say about but we need to do more research so what do I mean specifically so suppose there's no CPP
  115. suppose the EPA gets abolished okay there's no CVP there's nothing but individual states actually can act and
  116. decide to regulate themselves okay as long as you know what if Pennsylvania and Delaware individually decide to
  117. regulate themselves they might not be able to coordinate because they don't have this umbrella of the clean power
  118. plan but they can do you know by themselves these kinds of initiatives and we would be interested at these in
  119. future research we would like to see you know whether this kind of investment and
  120. reallocation has the same works in the same way in these kinds of environments so you know when something that the
  121. words looking at it for the next few once all right well good luck with that maybe we'll he'll be back to talk about
  122. I get some results thank you for thank you you

Brief Summary

Mike Abito discusses the Clean Power Plan's impact on CO2 emissions and investment in cleaner technologies.

Key points

  • The Clean Power Plan's Impact. The Clean Power Plan aims to reduce CO2 emissions through state-level implementation.
  • Unexpected Profit Findings. Research shows that state-by-state regulations can lead to higher profits than regional ones.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

More from Knowledge at Wharton