Is It Time To Rethink the Traditional Fixed-Rate Mortgage?

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Recent Wharton research looks at how lower interest rates impacted homeowners – with some surprising results. More: http://knlg.net/2eKWBkk 📂 Finance & Accounting;Real Estate;Public Policy 🏷️ Research

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. we're here today with Wharton real estate professor Ben keys to talk about some of his latest research Ben thanks
  2. for being here thanks for having me first of all could you give us basically a brief overview of your research what
  3. were you trying to find out yeah so a lot of my recent research has focused on trying to understand the role of
  4. monetary policy and how that transmits to households through the mortgage market so traditionally we've thought of
  5. the ways to stimulate the economy as being either through the fiscal side so through a tax rebate or through the
  6. monetary policy lowering of interest rates but the challenge is figuring out how those lower interest rates actually
  7. hit consumers pocketbooks and so in this project we're looking at the mortgage market as the key channel through which
  8. lower interest rates affect households and when interest rates were lowered in response to the Great Recession we were
  9. able to study this in much more detail this is natural experiment exactly so we had a time period unusually low interest
  10. rates and so that lowers the cost of borrowing for households who are not yet borrowing but in particular it benefits
  11. mortgage holders who can either refinance if they have a fixed rate mortgage or in the case of an adjustable
  12. rate mortgage on a mortgage that's indexed to the Treasury rate their interest rate falls automatically and
  13. their payments fall automatically and so one of the ways that we tried to study the pass-through of interest rates to
  14. households was looking at these automatic resets of adjustable rate mortgages the way that we tried to
  15. tackle this question was focus on two different types of adjustable rate mortgage borrowers borrowers that had a
  16. long fixed period and borrowers that had a short fixed period so one group would
  17. be exposed to lower interest rates sooner rather than later what we found was that the group of borrowers who were
  18. exposed sooner had interest rate reductions of about 175 basis points which if you translate that into dollars
  19. most people can't translate basis points into dollars in their head for the average loan it reduced their mortgage
  20. payments by about fifteen hundred dollars in the first year and thirty four hundred dollars over the first two
  21. years so let's compare that to a traditional tax rebate you might get a one-time check for five hundred dollars
  22. the was a much larger effect and something that benefited them throughout the life
  23. of the loan what we wanted to see was what was the impact of this reduction and we were able to take advantage of
  24. some amazing data that links mortgages to credit records so we could track the this reduction in payments through not
  25. just mortgage payments but also to the rest of the credit portfolio and what we found was that mortgage defaults fell
  26. thirty-six percent for this group who received this reduction in payments this monetary policy stimulus so a very large
  27. reduction in in default rates and that's not especially surprising if you lower people's mortgages their mortgage
  28. payments they're going to be more likely to make those payments what we thought was more interesting and more novel was
  29. the fact that we could track where those that reduction in payments was landing through the rest of their portfolio so
  30. we were able to see a reduction in credit card payments and credit card debt that they were about twenty percent
  31. of that reduction was going towards paying down credit cards and that was especially a large factor for those
  32. consumers who had a lot of credit card debt to begin with so they're taking this reduction in in mortgage payments
  33. and transferring that money to their highest cost debt so we sort of see the rebalancing of the household portfolio
  34. but we also see as households going out and spending that money in the form of buying new cars and so consumers who
  35. receive this reduction in mortgage payments relative to the group who were going to receive the reduction later
  36. they spent about ten percent of that quote-unquote monetary policy stimulus on new car purchases so are there other
  37. key takeaways that you found well one of the things that that we wanted to highlight in this study was the benefits
  38. of automatic transmission of monetary policy through adjustable rate mortgage contracts again the borrower doesn't
  39. have to do anything it just they get a letter in the mail that says congratulations your payment has fallen
  40. of course we're coming to a time period where interest rates might rise and they'll get the opposite letter sorry
  41. your payment's going to go up but that's a really strong stark contrast to the fixed rate case where you have to
  42. actively refinance your mortgage you have to pay attention to what the current rates are you
  43. need to reach out to a lender to be reevaluated and re underwritten for that loan many people who were underwater on
  44. their mortgage couldn't qualify for refinancing so there's a really nice benefit to adjustable rate mortgages
  45. through this automatic transmission of monetary policy which I think was underappreciated so I could see how this
  46. could have a lot of implications in particular for policy makers I mean what do you think are some of the practical
  47. takeaways from this well I think one of the challenges for policymakers going forward is to rethink the predominant
  48. mortgage contract which is the fixed 30 fixed-rate 30-year mortgage that's a contract that's been very popular
  49. popularized by Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac sort of in response to some short-term contracts coming out of the
  50. Great Depression and those contracts are really nice for borrowers in certain ways and really challenging for other
  51. types of borrowers so on the good side it's a fixed payment every month for 30 years you know exactly how much you're
  52. going to owe every month for 30 years and that type of stability allows you to make very long-term plans and it's very
  53. easy to assess whether you're going to be able to make that payment or not what the challenge of the fixed rate contract
  54. is that you have to actively refinance that contract and you have to be approved for that contract so when
  55. credit dries up as we saw it dry up in the wake of the Great Recession and standards are tightened there's going to
  56. be a large group of people who are going to be unable to refinance and this is what the harp program was designed to
  57. counteract we wouldn't need such an extensive harp program if more consumers were on adjustable rate mortgages and so
  58. the monetary policy impact would pass directly through through this automatic refinancing the risk there is that
  59. consumers are going to be bearing that upside risk as well that when rates rise their payments are going to go up and we
  60. might not think that a lot of low income households in particular should be facing that kind of risk that they
  61. should be insulated from future interest rate changes so I think one of the key policy takeaways is that in downturns
  62. adjustable rate mortgages look like a really convenient mechanism through through which households can benefit
  63. from from policy and the challenge going forward is to think about what's going to happen on the upside and what's next
  64. for this research so part of the part of the research going forward is going to focus on the impacts of of rate
  65. increases as we begin to see those so this is a project where we're waiting in the wings for the Fed to raise rates I'm
  66. not going to speculate on one that's going to happen sure but I think that as we see rates rise will see these types
  67. of adjustable rate mortgage contracts become costlier for borrowers and they're either going to want to
  68. refinance out of those or we're going to see the impact on their pocketbooks the
  69. other thing we'd like to study in more detail is the regional impacts that there are parts of the country where
  70. adjustable rate mortgages are more prevalent or less prevalent and in our existing work we've done some analysis
  71. looking at the regional impacts and shown that the regions of the country that had more of these adjustable rate
  72. mortgages where rates fell faster and payments fell faster they recovered faster during the great regret Great
  73. Recession so we saw increased house prices we saw more auto sales and we actually saw increased local employment
  74. in those parts of the countries so we want to do more to study the regional impacts and get a better understanding
  75. about how a national policy like setting interest rates can have really divergent
  76. impacts across different parts of the country it's been think so much for being here thanks for having me
  77. you

Brief Summary

Ben Keys discusses how monetary policy affects households via adjustable rate mortgages, highlighting significant payment reductions and consumer behavior changes.

Key points

  • The Role of Monetary Policy. Ben Keys discusses how monetary policy affects households through the mortgage market.
  • Impact of Interest Rate Reductions. Research shows significant reductions in mortgage payments can lower default rates.
  • Adjustable Rate Mortgages vs Fixed Rates. The study highlights the benefits of adjustable rate mortgages over fixed-rate contracts.

Tension

40/ 100Low tension

Related episodes