Q&A on the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
A Q&A by Knowledge@Wharton with Neal S. Wolin, Deputy Secretary U.S.Treasury. Deputy Secretary Wolin visited Wharton to discuss the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act. π Finance & Accounting
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- thank you i have a question about too big to fail if we do not limit the size of financial
- institutions and we have a failure even though the federal government can unwind that firm
- there would by definition be large losses so who absorbs those losses if they're
- massive and if not the u.s taxpayer who great question so first of all there are
- in this legislation i think um a range of things that either create size constraints or positive incentives
- not to grow beyond a certain size so as i said in my talk higher capital requirements if you're
- bigger and if you're more interconnected the legislation adds a kind of a modern
- day version of the deposit cap that currently applies to banks that looks at uh total assets on a
- risk-weighted basis so that you know the the problem with the current deposit cap is that it
- in a sense caps the safest kind of assets and and um uh and then sends people to go
- elsewhere if they want to grow and a range of things that fundamentally are um uh risk constraining but i think the
- question nonetheless obviously valid the way the legislation works is that modeled on the fidicia current fiduciary
- authorities that exist for the government with respect to banks that bank holding companies or non-bank
- financial institutions that are of a certain size can if they become insolvent will be broken up
- be done so in a way that is designed to insulate the broader financial system from the kind of contagion effect that
- was so prevalent in this last round of crisis this is meant to be paid for in the
- first instance from the assets of the firm that is being broken up but insofar as the predicate is
- insolvency the whatever increment um and oh by the way i mean i haven't gone through it but the
- whole point of having higher capital standards and and leveraged constraints and so forth
- and so on is to minimize the chance of this happening but in the case uh uh that you suggest
- um to the extent that the estate of the firm that's being broken up is insufficient to pay the costs
- then financial firms uh will be levied for that cost not the taxpayer the statute very
- explicit on this question the fdic will levy a charge basically x post on financial firms big financial firms
- who in our judgment and in the judgment of the congress after all would be the principal beneficiaries of
- the notion that the contagion effect will be dampened by this new process and that
- the financial system will be well protected so uh first recourse is to uh the firm and
- it's you know it's capital stack um it's it's common equity holders uh and so forth um
- and beyond that uh financial firms thank you there's been a lot of effort to to create a more stable situation in
- the financial system these regulations among them and and to help put wall street on a
- firmer footing but main street is still suffering a lot and just today there was an announcement
- that weekly initial unemployment claims increased to almost 480 000 and that means that the four-week moving average
- has basically been stuck for about eight months now so what more could be done for unemployment
- more immediately than just waiting for a recovery to come which many people think is going to be very
- slow in coming so there's no question there is as i suggested in my talk still an
- enormous amount of pain across america felt by individuals and families and small businesses
- the result of a very very deep recession that we faced in 2008 and the beginning of 2009
- i think there are now increasingly signs of a moderate recovery that is beginning to build
- we have had now four quarters in a row of growth six months in a row of job growth um
- there is still a lot more work to be done uh and so uh the president uh the secretary
- of the treasury the administration generally very focused on making sure that the government provides
- the appropriate basis for stimulus while understanding that ultimately it's for the private sector
- really to generate jobs as it has done in the united states we're focused on creating the conditions
- for that to happen and for that to happen at a rate that continues and ticks upward
- um so congress is considering an additional stimulus package the senate acted on it last night the house is
- going to come back in session briefly next tuesday to act on it that's an important piece
- there is pending in congress small business legislation that would provide incentives for small banks to extend
- credit to small businesses a set of tax cuts that are targeted at small businesses that are really focused
- on job creation and economic growth we think that that's important legislation it has the
- support not only of the president but of the chamber of commerce and of the small business community
- and we think that's an important piece and so we believe that we are on a trajectory that is positive
- as you note the data that comes in is not is not even so although we've added jobs
- each of the last six months uh the week to week data and sometimes the month-to-month month
- data has a certain amount of unevenness to it and we what it reminds us is we have
- substantial more work to to do i think if you look at where we are today relative to where we were a year ago or
- 18 months ago we feel like we've made uh very very important improvements really on the basis of some
- really decisive stands that the president took and that the congress took with respect to fiscal stimulus
- with respect to efforts to repair the financial system and now legislation that both reforms the health care system and
- the financial services framework and we will keep on this path looking at ways to create
- jobs through near-term stimulus so that's what the legislation that's about to pass the congress will do
- looking for ways to create additional incentives for the private sector to to grow i would note that if you look
- at the uh gdp numbers that were released last week they suggest i think an important
- increase in the level of business investment and of private sector consumption that
- are i think further signs that this recovery is starting to take hold and to build and
- these other efforts that i've identified are meant to continue that along to help transfer the
- the job creation to the private sector which is where it ought to happen and should
- happen and to do so in a way that is um also responsible and credible within a broader fiscal context that our country
- has over the um over the longer the intermediate and longer term hi public policy seems to focus a lot on
- startups and small businesses since those are regarded as engines of job creation but in the u.s
- although middle market companies account for about 6 trillion in revenues and 32 million employees i mean what has
- been your policy so far to provide incentives in that sector and what steps do you plan to take in
- the future to strengthen it further well i think if you look at the administration's efforts
- partly related to the recovery act fiscal piece partly related to the tax initiatives of the administration
- there's a lot of focus on investment in healthcare in green energy and a range of things that span sort of
- businesses small medium-sized bigger businesses so the focus on small businesses by no
- means meant to be exclusive of focus on finding ways to generate growth and job creation across
- the range of businesses by size or by geography or for that matter by sector and i think you'll continue to
- see a set of tax policies that are focused on trying to generate research and development and
- technological innovation that both create near-term growth but also and importantly are focused on things
- that are important to the longer term health of our economy and of our country uh in in other sorts of ways so whether
- it's energy or healthcare education uh so forth you spoke really eloquently about the reforms of the 1930s
- and the criticisms that were made and what the outcome was but clearly those reforms didn't prevent
- crises in the in the future including the most recent one so my question is if you were to look at the dodd-frank
- act do you believe it will prevent future crises and if not what financial risks does it fail to
- address and what do you plan to do about those risks that's a good challenging question for
- the last one so first i guess i'd start by saying um although what you say about the
- sort of spate of legislative activity in the 30s is true it is also true that for 60 or 70 years
- or more that essential framework the one that was created in that sort of couple year period in the early mid 30s
- established a framework that allowed our financial services um our financial markets and our
- financial services sector to um uh exist on a stable strong platform in ways that allow it to generate you
- know to intermediate an enormous amount of investment and innovation and economic
- growth the likes of which the world has never seen and it is true of course and we see it now we know it empirically
- that at some point that extraordinary set of things that were put in place at that time
- um outlive their capacity to actually protect the system and there's a range of reasons for that
- um and you know the literature is already big and it's getting bigger by the nanosecond as to what exactly
- you know the causes were and and all of the sort of the ideology if you will of the
- crisis um but it was awfully good for an awfully long time in the envy of the world and i would make the strong
- argument you know the best it's ever been so now we need a new set of things and that's
- really what we've just been about trying to create in our in the continuing process of creating
- you know my crystal ball is not uh 70 years clear might not be seven weeks probably not
- seven days clear um but um but i think that the goal here was to create a framework that
- that had the capacity to to deal with to bend to to to be flexible to a financial services
- world a set of markets that morph at a shocking pace uh that are changing and innovating
- with lightning speed and that create the governance structures and the authorities
- to allow the government to do things that will substantially lessen the probability of
- crisis so all the things i mentioned and other things as well but the core of it i mentioned looking at
- the big most complicated forms the kinds of firms that have the capacity to create that
- problems at on that scale and treating them in a very different more consolidated sort of more synoptic
- kind of way to make sure that the basic prudential rules are a bunch more robust
- that you know buffers are higher the margin of error is extended a whole bunch to make sure that you know opportunities
- for arbitrage in the system are squeezed out that gaps where risk started to build up the non-bank
- sector being you know broadly speaking kind of a classic thing the derivatives markets another broadly
- speaking big thing are treated and treated seriously but to give the government tools
- to adjust its approach over time as the world turns and as markets innovate and as our understanding of risk
- changes and advances and then importantly to make sure that the government also has
- a set of tools on the back end so that if there is stress again and you know there will be stress again
- the government has a better capacity to deal with it than it did over these last few years
- where the options were thin and they were pretty uh sub sub optimal and and you know and we saw
- kind of you know what happened so this is not meant to be a magic elixir this is meant to be a serious rigorous
- set of rules that we think has the fundamental basis covered the things that not just
- relate to fighting the last war which is the tendency of folks in government and out of government to
- do but also to create the the flexibility to fight wars uh if i could use that metaphor again that we can't conceive of
- quite yet but that will no doubt be coming around the corner you
Brief Summary
The episode covers financial regulations, unemployment issues, and the Dodd-Frank Act's effectiveness in preventing future crises.
Key points
- The Question of Absorbing Losses. Who absorbs the massive losses if financial institutions fail?
- Legislation for Financial Stability. New legislation aims to prevent contagion effects in financial crises.
- Unemployment Claims Rise. Weekly initial unemployment claims increased to almost 480,000, indicating ongoing economic pain.
- Signs of Recovery. There are signs of a moderate recovery with job growth over the last six months.
- Focus on Small Businesses. Legislation aims to provide incentives for small banks to extend credit to small businesses.
Episode highlights
- The Question of Absorbing LossesWho absorbs the massive losses if financial institutions fail?βGreat question!β0:38Aug 18, 2010
- Legislation for Financial StabilityNew legislation aims to prevent contagion effects in financial crises.βThe legislation adds a kind of a modern day version of the deposit cap.β1:09Aug 18, 2010
- Unemployment Claims RiseWeekly initial unemployment claims increased to almost 480,000, indicating ongoing economic pain.βMain street is still suffering a lot.β3:50Aug 18, 2010
- Signs of RecoveryThere are signs of a moderate recovery with job growth over the last six months.βWe have had now four quarters in a row of growth.β4:41Aug 18, 2010
- Focus on Small BusinessesLegislation aims to provide incentives for small banks to extend credit to small businesses.βThis is important legislation.β5:40Aug 18, 2010
Episode quotes
Tension
45/ 100Some tension





