The Candidates on Taxes: Finding the Devil in the Details
Ask about Knowledge at Wharton
Episode Description
The two U.S. presidential candidates may paint themselves as agents for a new, more bipartisan attitude in Washington, but Republican Sen. John McCain and Democratic Sen. Barack Obama both tend to adhere to their parties' usual approaches to tax policy. Obama proposes to raise taxes on the wealthy and reduce them for the middle class; McCain proposes to sustain the tax cuts enacted by the Bush administration. But neither candidate fully explains how they will pay the bills. This is the first in a series of articles from Knowledge@Wharton examining economic and fiscal policies proposed by the candidates. 📂 Public Policy
Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
- this podcast is brought to you by knowledge at Wharton please visit knowledge Wharton upendi d you for more
- information that's the part of the calculus that's very unclear at this point am and it's neither candidate has
- a very clear plan on it they both are basically appealing to the vague language of will find the inefficiencies
- somewhere in the budget and will cut those things out but when persons efficiency is another person subsidy and
- so it's very hard to find those things and so what you see before the election will actually happens after the election
- are often two very different things I think you know the best way of trying to answer that question is to look at track
- record and in particular McKeen's plan will cause probably a little larger deficit than Obama's not so much but
- McCain also does have more of a track record voting against government's spending trying to cut government
- spending in fact one example is that he actually voted against Medicare Part D which is quite remarkable coming good
- night comes from Arizona the second-most agent state and he's actually never lobby they were putting a bill a single
- earmark during this entire career and so that's I think he has more of a track record of cutting spending on the other
- hand Obama has advantage to being a Democrat so when it actually comes to cutting spending he'll actually be may
- be trusted more with that and so I think what at the same time his track record his short track record is not as
- compelling he's had lobbied for earmarks for his district and he's never been kind of a color in terms of government
- spending and so on when he and he had mckean with kind of the track record of cutting who will have a harder time as a
- Republican doing it another hand you have Obama who had probably more naturally trusted the Democrat to do it
- but doesn't have the track record so the theorem what's called divided government can suggest both ways in
- particular on one hand having a divided government the idea is that it's supposed to just constantly constant
- roadblocks it's very hard to get increases in government spending because it's hard to get a bill through Congress
- that's actually can be signed by the President and so forth but when it actually comes to cutting spending it
- may be actually to Obama's advantage because he does have a cooperative party and so he has to kind of get them on
- board and use the power of the White House for that so again I think politically it's going to a little bit
- easier on Obama that the problem is is that he doesn't have the maverick track record that McCain has
- there's no question that tax cut is a perfect place for thinking about distribution equity and efficiency in
- terms of economic growth in fact it's the key area at the same time I think the Obama side they really want to focus
- on what we call the deltas that is they want to look at past tax changes and say
- lots of those accrued to the rich and therefore we were we want to reverse those it whereas they don't what they
- don't report as much as what we call the levels actually reporting what is the actual distribution of the tax burden
- between middle-class and rich and so what they do is they are in some ways exploiting a misconception that
- misconception is that most Americans believe is that the middle class pays the taxes it's not true at the top 10%
- of the income earners pay majority of the taxes it used to be true before the 1986 Tax Reform Act the tax reform 1986
- Tax Reform Act really close down lots of loopholes and so forth today the rich pay actually most of the taxes and so
- when we think about what's the ideal tax system we shouldn't just look at how a tax plan impact one group versus the
- other group what we should actually look as the resulting state what type of how
- much taxes do we want levied on the rich versus the poor it presumably we want a
- higher tax rate and a rich then on the poor for equity reasons and but for efficiency reasons we don't want the tax
- rates to go so high in the wrist they are in fact many of the job creators and so we want to have that that type a
- trade-off but we shouldn't just look at the changes we should actually look as the resulting levels that that a
- particular tax change and the fact of the matter is McCain plan will actually result again in the top 10% of the
- income earners pain most of the taxes that's like I change on are either either plan
- but this is a part of the rhetoric that's very confused in the people technically these tax cuts do sunset in
- 2011 and so by extending them you know is that a tax cut or not just huge debate about language I think it's
- irrelevant and the reason why it's irrelevant because i don't think the right focus should be on what's the
- impact of the change on each particular group what I think the right in analysis
- should be is what is the resulting n that is what is the level of taxes that we should expect they have from
- high-income earners versus middle versus low and in so give you a simple example
- if i told you that the top 10% p ninety percent of the tax as well if it's cut taxes most of the tax cuts are going to
- accrue to the top 10% just pure math and so that's not a group therefore a regressive tax cut it's just attributing
- it's just the natural result of the original level while the top ten percent actually pay about sixty sixty-five
- percent depending what year that you look at the total other income tax revenue they paid in some years was even
- higher than that in the 70s and so you know what we really should ask ourselves from a distribution perspective is is
- that the type of allocation that we we like and so when we cut taxes across the board yeah lots of its going to accrue
- to them that's only because they're paying law texas to begin with right so that's why it's not fair i think to look
- at the change it's what you really want to look at is kind of the actual resulting level that you end up with and
- also for in terms of efficiency that is production in the economy you don't care
- about the change impact what you care about as a result in level and so that's where mckean the Obama plans are going
- to differ a fair amount and partly it depends on how you interpret the Obama fix of the Social Security tax and that
- is he's been unclear he said one thing where he basically said he wants to lift the cap on Social Security taxes that
- would result in a dramatic increase in marginal tax rates of higher income people his advisors however say he's not
- actually going to propose that he just wants have a tax surcharge and the higher income people well
- difference between those two things what the one he eventually comes out with could have a dramatic impact
- the deficit certainly matters for each plan but at the same time I think the distribution of the taxes do matter I
- mean I think we my own opinion is that we do want a progressive tax system the question is how much you really want to
- hit the higher income people right versus middle income and lower income and again most Americans really believe
- that the middle income people pay the taxes and exhaust it is not actually true it's it is most of the taxes are
- actually paid by the rich and when I told my beetle and come class friends include my consider myself fairly
- middle-income class they don't want to believe that they say I'm definitely wrong but the data is pretty clear
- oh and those numbers don't help up a small portion of the truth because they rely simply on this my opinion
- fraudulent government accounting scheme which ignores how much we're accruing in
- the big entitlement program Social Security Medicare and so forth I went testified before Congress that if they
- did this up by counting the private sector the CEO as we go to jail it could actually be illegal basically I duns my
- own calculations and if you actually brought in the increase in liabilities and Medicare Social Security Medicaid
- all the entire government liabilities the true deficit is not in the 450 to 500 range it's actually about 2.5
- trillion dollars much larger and that's that's just the increase in liabilities across all spending minus tax programs
- and Medicare is the much bigger problem it's actually about six this shortfall in the Medicare program is about six
- times larger than Social Security and it's also a harder problem to fix with Social Security there's actually some
- easy fixes that may I don't want to make it sound like it's without pain but the
- Bush administration and mckean have talked about scaling back benefits for higher income earners by scaling back
- from the dollar benefits having those grow just with inflation and not faster than inflation for lower-income actually
- have them grow faster inflation so it tilts it makes it more progressive that type of change alone could go a long way
- to solving the social security problem Medicare very difficult problem to solve not only is it is the shortfall think of
- six times larger but how do you cut it debt is do you say world will pay for half the operation it's not a dollar
- benefit it's an in-kind benefit and so it's much harder to cut that type of program because now the government's in
- the position where they have to start saying you know we'll pay for that type of surgery but not this type of surgery
- right involves very tough moral decisions so what happen whether care Part D it's
- the first rule of temp and Part D pays for prescription drugs it's a very first attempt to get some type of income or
- what's called means-testing into the system right that's going to be a very natural way to go with the other parts
- and mainly Parts A and B that pays for hospitalization outpatient services at the same time it's going to be you know
- very difficult to tell some higher income people that G with something that you are getting before is not going to
- happen and they keep in mind is that you don't just have to hit high high income
- people it's a lot of people who don't see themselves as high income will it would actually get hit by this it make a
- dramatic point if you to balance Medicare and Social Security going out into the into the future we would have
- to immediately cut benefits by over fifty percent in both of the programs to create balance that's how much we're
- overspending and present value and and that's immediately no one's proposing that no one's going to cut your
- grandma's you know Medicare benefit immediately so if you delay it twenty or thirty years you phase it in it's even
- more dramatic cuts that I needed and most of that is due the Medicare and so this these are very dramatic changes
- that are going to have to happen if they don't happen we're going to have to raise more money through taxes that's
- going to slow economic growth a or we're going to have a serious day of reckoning
- I mean people talk about the type of things that happen in Asian currency crisis and Latin America debt crisis
- that those things can't happen America well that's what they thought in those countries to it can happen in America
- for more information please visit knowledge wharton you Penn dot edu Oh
Brief Summary
The episode compares McCain's and Obama's economic plans, focusing on spending cuts, tax distribution, and Medicare reforms.
Key points
- The Tax Burden Misconception. Most Americans mistakenly believe the middle class pays the majority of taxes, but it's actually the top 10%.
- The True Deficit Revealed. The actual deficit is significantly larger than reported, at about 2.5 trillion dollars.
- Dramatic Cuts Ahead. Future Medicare and Social Security cuts could exceed fifty percent if spending isn't controlled.
Episode highlights
- The Tax Burden MisconceptionMost Americans mistakenly believe the middle class pays the majority of taxes, but it's actually the top 10%.“It's not true.”7:42Sep 11, 2008
- The True Deficit RevealedThe actual deficit is significantly larger than reported, at about 2.5 trillion dollars.“It's actually about 2.5 trillion dollars.”8:45Sep 11, 2008
- Dramatic Cuts AheadFuture Medicare and Social Security cuts could exceed fifty percent if spending isn't controlled.“It's even more dramatic cuts that are needed.”11:38Sep 11, 2008





