How Tech Transforms Economies

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Wharton professor Karl Ulrich talks with Iqbal Quadir, founder of GrameenPhone in Bangladesh, about how he built a network with 55 million subscribers from scratch. More: http://knlg.net/1PD1fLr 📂 Innovation;Management

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. I'm Carl Olrich, vice dean of entrepreneurship and innovation at the Wharton School and I'm very lucky to be
  2. able to interview today Kadir who's the founder of two amazing institutions, Grammine Phone and the Legatum Center at
  3. MIT. Welcome. Thank you very much. Great to be here. You know I want to take us back to your origins. Tell tell us a
  4. little bit about where you came from. I I came from Bangladesh but uh I came from a relatively smaller town called
  5. Jasur and uh I grew up there and I happened to have gone to a boarding school inside Bangladesh but um
  6. um since you're asking the what has impacted on me which I guess we could come to is uh that one year of my life I
  7. was somewhat of a urban uh kid uh but in 1971 when there was a war in the country. I went to the rural area for my
  8. family did and um we I had experienced the actual rural conditions in Bangladesh during that year. So I my
  9. friends were often u children of peasants and other small farmers and that had always had an impact on me and
  10. so that's I I talk about that. Yeah. And how did you end up in the United States?
  11. Um, I guess I was an entrepreneur. I I don't know. But uh my father died when I was 14 years old and I somehow aspired
  12. to get a good education and I my mother and uh had provided some funds but I managed to get to the US with some
  13. scholarships and eventually I got uh better and almost full scholarship and uh so that's how I simply tried myself.
  14. Yeah, that's a that's a common path for some of our most successful entrepreneurs in the United States and
  15. and so you you there there are a lot of others who've taken that path and and like the many of those others you also
  16. achieved some entrepreneurial success. So I wonder if you could tell us a little bit about Grammy and Phone. Sure.
  17. uh Gramm fund right now is the largest company in the country uh in Bangladesh and it has 55 million subscribers.
  18. Sometimes in the stock market it's valued some7 billion dollars. But uh if I go back it was really uh for four or
  19. five years I tried to convince people that this is a good idea this is something to be pursued and it took
  20. quite a while to convince that but I think if we want to go back to its origin uh it's good that you asked me
  21. about my personal origin uh those impacts had certain u germ of thoughts that eventually gave rise to uh gramming
  22. phone and um and this is why I think it's important that no matter how we rigorously we think about problems uh
  23. deeper at a deeper level passions are important because it drives us to find a logical solution but uh even behind
  24. logic you may have uh a passionate u pursuit which gives rise to finding a logical solution. So in my case, I knew
  25. that I came to America and there were extraordinary opportunities here uh in the United States. I managed to go to
  26. good schools with scholarships and whatnot, but I uh also had in mind the conditions I've seen in Bangladesh and
  27. so therefore I always on the lookout for uh good ideas that could do something about it. So two really important ideas
  28. uh stuck me in I was doing that. One is that um the economic progress does not necessarily come from um pouring capital
  29. into it or something but rather people becoming more efficient uh in managing their tasks or getting better at it. So
  30. it's a question of improvements or or skills but also how uh let's say in a sense economic progress can come out of
  31. thin air. I I'll give you the point. Um so for instance I was actually attracted
  32. to Adam Smith because he mentioned uh Bengal which is Bangladesh. Twothird of Bengal is Bangladesh. That is how I was
  33. originally drawn to it. And he mentioned an interesting thing. He said in antiquity three places had good um um
  34. good wealth and they were ancient Egypt, Bengal and Eastern China. And he attributed those things to uh inland
  35. navigation. And his point is that people could exchange and through inland navigation um tra specialize in exchange
  36. and divide in division of labor and through that wealth is created and through that uh there was he called it
  37. opulence in antiquity and that has drawn me and that I as a result I always became a fan of Adam Smith but what is
  38. interesting is that many things come out of division of labor. many good things okay including inclusivity because if I
  39. want to specialize in something I have to give up something else to you okay so that gives rise to inclusivity now be
  40. but what is interesting of all of that is that it's uh it's something I learned over
  41. time I frankly didn't grasp it all over immediately but uh but I did see the inland navigation as a means of
  42. communication that naturally certain places had certain other places didn't have. Okay. But separately I had another
  43. I'll come back to the another Adam Smith point but separately I had another uh important thing I observed is when I was
  44. an undergraduate I was part of a uh college team. I mean I was the only token student representative in this
  45. team that decided on buying a $3 million computer. Okay. and one big mainframe that took a whole room full of
  46. machinery. And then in the when I was doing my graduate studies here at Wharton, okay, I was in decision
  47. sciences with computers. We learned all sorts of applications of computers. But the key point is there's this Moors law
  48. that's driving down costs and processing power is getting squeezed more and more
  49. into the same chips. But the Moors law means the prices of this processing power is declining rapidly which means
  50. countries that doesn't have very much capital these machines are going towards them. Okay. So I actually tried in the
  51. middle of ' 80s with another brother of mine. We created a Bengali word processor. Okay. But later on we
  52. realized that that it was an interesting innovation to take. But I'm trying to show you the evolution of this that um
  53. the Bengali word processor people couldn't use at least not not the masses because um it's a um most people do not
  54. know how to read or write. Okay. But an event took place in my life in the 93. By this time I've been trying to be a
  55. budding investment banker. And the point is that um I I noticed that uh we I was
  56. to work in a a small firm that had um uh we just had some rudimentary networks. So we didn't have to exchange floppy
  57. disc and cumbersome activities. So we could send data from one to another etc. And one time it broke down and I was
  58. waiting for someone to come and fix it. But that reminded me of a day in 1971 22 years earlier. This is in 93 or so.
  59. And I um remember my mother sent me to get some medicine from this rural setting. And uh I was from a middle-ass
  60. family. My father was a lawyer and all these things. But uh in this setting, I walked 10 kilometers to get this
  61. medicine. And when I went there, the medicine man wasn't there. So I walked all afternoon back. And as a result I
  62. remembered that unproductive day sitting in New York while having waiting for someone to come and fix my network and
  63. kind of said you know networks help. So if you are connected you can get things done and if you don't get connected then
  64. you don't get things done. So this inland navigation earlier in my mind I went back to all those things and I
  65. realized a new thing which is that two things. One is the microchips are getting squeezed in into phones. In the
  66. early '90s they were becoming digital phones. Before that cellular phones were analog phones. But at this point I also
  67. realized a powerful point from Adam Smith that there were many things that come out of division of labor
  68. and division of labor gives rise to productivity. So just like I experienced that if I had connections I could
  69. produce more and perhaps pay for the phone service. Similarly, this is confirmed by the one of the most
  70. profound economies, okay? That the it will promote division of labor if we can connect with each other. Otherwise, I
  71. cannot really divide and do one part and you do another part, we can exchange. But what he made also he said the market
  72. the extent of the market dep tells you how far you'd be dividing. So let's say I start focusing on fishing but I will
  73. stop there and not necessarily go any further and fishing only salmons. Okay. If the market is small okay if the
  74. market is bigger and bigger then I can uh specialize narrower and narrower but that means and all the other good things
  75. come out of this division of labor. Okay. But if we did that then other means of connectivity profoundly impacts
  76. on the size of the market. So the point is the the ways to connect determines how far the market will be and how far
  77. the division of labor will advance. And all of this made sense to me. So ultimately I realized that if the the
  78. Moore's law is bringing down the price of connectivity, connectivity would be a profound force of of transforming these
  79. countries and it became so I became so convinced of this because of these insights of these other people. I'm
  80. basically stealing their ideas. I basically said hey I have to stay put on this. So I stayed for five six years
  81. convincing various parties to come together and create this company. I jokingly say that that's how I lost my
  82. hair. Now it's it's amazing because you're really saying not only does private enterprise and entrepreneurship
  83. contribute to an economy but particular kinds of innovations these connectivity innovations. Exactly. Exactly. So it's
  84. it's little bit like this. You see I I I like analogies to understand what's happening. Let's say if I take a bucket
  85. of water, if I drop a a drop of ink, even without stirring, it will get absorbed. And so if it is something
  86. favorable, the molecules other molecules will receive them. So in other words, people
  87. will accept them. But if you put a let's say a drop of water, oil, it may not go
  88. very far. Okay? So if you find the right technology then it will be grabbed by people okay
  89. and the whole water will get transformed okay the the whole economy gets transformed so the I think the cell
  90. phone was such a thing because it's fundamentally a elementally human to connect and and produce more and gain
  91. more sometimes it's consumption I want to contact my friends and see how it is doing but sometimes it's production
  92. namely I want to save time and produce more etc. So it depends on how it is but it is very elemental and at the same
  93. time the cost of these things radically going down things automatically come together and so it's the question of
  94. bringing it together and seeing that it's um frankly to me it's almost surreal but if it is like a
  95. country like Bangladesh everybody knows is one of the lowest income countries um
  96. there right now we have 110 million phones And when I started it had a quarter million fixed ones.
  97. Okay. So it's a really a profound change to know to say the least. Yeah. Now I I
  98. wonder if you could speak to the barriers to entrepreneurial innovation in developing economies. You've spoken
  99. very eloquently about the power of enterprise in developing economies. What do you see? What have been the the
  100. barriers the legacy barriers? Yeah. All all innovations I think human beings cannot radically absorb something
  101. completely radically new. It's hard. Okay. So uh similarly innovations has to ride on other things. Okay. So for
  102. instance I there were a lot of things I sorted out in my head and I said this is
  103. why I'm talking about these insights and I said this is what gave me the resilience the patience to try it
  104. because I believed in those insights and those insights were logical and made sense to me but there are actual
  105. practical problems okay and perhaps you were asking about that but one of those practical problems is lack of other
  106. things. So for example, let's say I bring a good car but without the highway I cannot drive the car. Okay. So
  107. internet for example in the same early 1990s internet were spreading in this country very rapidly. It was very easy
  108. to notice. Um so people already had computers, they had modem, they had telephone lines, they could easily call
  109. up something and internet was spreading. But the real problem in poor countries is that you don't have those other
  110. infrastructures. Now because of colonialism uh and subsequent adriven statedriven
  111. development central uh centralized planning even if it's not a communist country tend to be the case it is tend
  112. even in India you'll see different states and within those states there is central and so usual pattern in these
  113. countries are one central city often being um supporting a big in um bureaucratic infrastructure
  114. and vast parts of rural areas uh relatively underdeveloped with no infrastructure and what happens it
  115. creates a vicious cycle because because the infrastructures are there everybody develops things within that area okay so
  116. even if you want to start something you don't want to go out in the rural areas and uh not have your children go to good
  117. schools so you kind of avoid that okay but this case here is the problem I knew through Mo's law and through the Adam
  118. Smith thing that this is ultimately useful because it's Mo's law would say it's it would it would be viable
  119. everywhere and Adam Smith said it will be useful everywhere okay so then the problem is that how can I break that
  120. vicious cycle because I too do not have engineers to go out in the world where there's nothing or there is no lack of
  121. electricity all these problem and this is why I try to latch on to another organization that may have calm
  122. infrastructure and this is why I went to microcredit programs and somehow Bangladesh was blessed with good micro
  123. credit programs and Grammine Bank for instance had um 10,00 branches I thought oh maybe I could put the cell towers
  124. over there and this is why by the way our name has become in their honor Grammine phone okay but my original idea
  125. was gonophone which means phones for the masses and the daring see because I'm bringing this insight It's because that
  126. is how I projected it's will be feasible because I was talking about phone for the masses in a poor country when only
  127. 1% of Americans had mobile phones in the days I I started this process. Okay. So
  128. but again I was basing myself on those insights. Okay. But coming back to this, this is why I try to the one of the
  129. problems you're talking about is the ecology being poorer. Okay. To bring something new. Okay. So, if you have an
  130. let's say Amazon.com is a company that's selling books or other things, but people have credit cards. Well, you can
  131. base that on you need those other infrastructure to bring about a new thing. And this is not a conceptual
  132. problem. It's a practical problem that you need to solve. And so Grammine Bank, not only I could find those sites where
  133. I could potentially put cell towers and some some infrastructure to help out that process, but also there were
  134. borrowers and eventually I developed an idea and I proposed it to Grammine Bank that they would give money to somebody
  135. to borrow uh borrow small amount of money, $100, $200 to buy vegetable growing facilities or ducks or chicken
  136. or a typical loan was a cow loan. And so I said, you know, the cell phone could be a cow because somebody could borrow
  137. $200 um instead of a cow, get a phone and the phone would serve the village, but it
  138. would pay the p it would be a business for that person. And that idea was was um was a little crazy, but it was
  139. considered illogical. But so the founder of Brain Bank, Mhammed said, "Why don't you see if you
  140. can make it happen?" So I quit my job. I went there and I flew around the world.
  141. I got some seed funding from New York and uh I faced many rejections. But eventually I managed to convince the
  142. Norwegian telephone company. Ah they came and interestingly they have never been to Asia before. Wow. This is
  143. Teleno. So Teleno and they were very reluctant to come and subsequently they saw this is a great opportunity and
  144. today they are very big in Asia. Yeah. So I want to I want to talk about that for a minute because the normal view of
  145. entrepreneurship in the developing world that says that that is the view held by
  146. most of us in the developed world is that all this great stuff gets invented in the developed world and then it
  147. trickles down to the to developing economies. Is are we missing something? Is there a different way to view this?
  148. Well, in this case, it somewhat trickled down. Yeah, somewhat but rapidly trickled down because of the Moore's law
  149. which says which is which is only a decade later the same amount of processing power becomes 200th or so.
  150. Okay. So you can even if we throw out all the details it becomes $100 becomes $1 in 10 years. That does go down
  151. rapidly. That's one issue. Okay. And the other is that it is so fundamentally useful. It's an egalitarian thing. So I
  152. was totally wrong in chasing computers. Okay, that's when I realized that no when I when I saw that connectivity is
  153. helpful, I also realized at the same time that it's and Adam Smith and all that is there but you know it's a
  154. culmination of a lot of things but the other point is it's egalitarian. Everybody can talk. Okay. And so in a
  155. way there is an irony of all this. The point is the cell phones are actually computers. So the computers have entered
  156. these markets in the disguise of a phone. Okay? And so so because the voice communication is the killer app, okay?
  157. And everybody can talk. But now what is happening is that these computers are now that they're there, they're kind of
  158. a Trojan horse that can do all sorts of other things. Okay? And so when you say trickle down, yes, but if you look at
  159. Telenor's example, yes, typically a let's say a um western company goes to Asia, first they go to
  160. Hong Kong, Singapore, Japan or something and then they will go to poorer and poorer places that would I would say
  161. trickle down. Okay, for whatever reason, maybe because I banged on their door for
  162. many times, okay, they somehow came to Bangladesh. Okay, before they went to any other uh Asian country, okay, and
  163. frankly it took them few years. They may not admit it now, but it took them few years to there were some very good
  164. people who did this. But what I'm trying to and it got endorsement from the top of Telenor. But I personally think it
  165. they thought it's a good thing to do. Okay, socially, socially speaking, okay, but they had some officially some
  166. motivation to make money, but they also thought it's a good thing to do. After all, Norway was the poorest Western
  167. European country and now they their things they have developed very well and fast after World War II. Norway was the
  168. poorest country in Western Europe. Okay, now by the way it's very expensive place
  169. to go and okay so what I'm saying they they may have had little bit of that mindset and they have seen their own
  170. country develop. So they came and after four five years they saw this is indeed becoming very profitable and so now they
  171. have close to 200 million subscribers in Asia. So Bangladesh, Pakistan, India, Myanmar they had gone to Thailand,
  172. Malaysia etc. But the bottom line is what is an interesting thing that has evolved not necessarily I saw it all
  173. that the the western world is providing an innovation but the low so-called low-income country
  174. is providing a market and I think that's a very healthy dubtail arrangement interest of both worlds and that is an
  175. interesting model that uh American business schools should look at and so it's not and what I like about it
  176. there's another aspect of it that is interesting it's not necessarily selling um consumer goods okay again consumer
  177. goods have their own good purposes but the point is this is empowering people so somebody is spending let's say two
  178. pennies to make a phone call and is saving him a quarter worth of time then he is advancing by 23 cents okay so
  179. these people are actually advancing. So I personally think that the cell phone revolution in Bangladesh is at least
  180. producing I can show some back of the envelope calculation uh at least producing $20 billion a year to say the
  181. least. Okay, because it's simply millions of people if more oper efficiently. So what I'm trying to say
  182. if we have productivity tools supplied by western innovations then let the innovators make money and let the
  183. low-income people provide the market but they also advance. Yeah, both are advancing. Okay. Today I would say that
  184. Bangladesh is giving uh more aid to Norway through dividends than uh Norway might be giving some aid to Bangladesh
  185. and you know this is um I think that's the way it should be. I mean we are a bigger country uh we are warm bigger
  186. country they are a small cold country. I think it's perfectly good arrangement. So interesting. So you're saying
  187. something actually quite profound. I think again we would often characterize impact entrepreneurship, right, as
  188. people want to do good in the world. They want to use entrepreneurship and enterprise as the as the vehicle. You're
  189. saying something slightly different, which is that in some cases pure greed actually is is is fine. That that in
  190. fact some of these opportunities are exceptionally valuable economic opportunities. I think so. But again, we
  191. can restrain ourselves with our conscience. Okay. But remember the ultimate restraint comes from people. So
  192. sometimes we are may we may restrain ourselves through our own internal police and say oh I won't go there and I
  193. will restrain my greed. But the as people become more empowered through economic uh wherewithal they are also
  194. able to create more checks and balances. So ultimately it is a good thing. But what I'm also trying to say is that if
  195. we find fantastic innovations, okay, that are empowering at the bottom, then those innovations
  196. are to be embraced and people advance this way. And remember another thing, this kind of capital, we're not talking
  197. about Marxist worries. We're not talking about a big factory where some capitalist may potentially quote unquote
  198. exploit people. We're talking about people simply uh becoming more efficient with their fellow citizens. Okay? And as
  199. a result, all the value they create often acrew to them themselves. Okay? And at the same time, there's a viable
  200. business. The business makes billions of dollars in revenues and very good dividends. Okay? So, but this can be a
  201. model for other kinds of innovations that are perfectly in sync with each other's needs through innovations. But
  202. there's another one other issue. Remember, cell phone was not invented for the poor countries. Okay? So, too
  203. much planning is not necessarily necessary. Okay? It was an unintended consequence. What I'm saying is that we
  204. need to go into the reservoir of various innovations we have in this in the first
  205. world and pick out those that we can tweak and make it available for uh lower income people and their income
  206. automatically rising is is uh then they can buy things from the western world more even not just the phones they can
  207. buy generators they can buy other things. So what I'm trying to say that what is really necessary is remember the
  208. two things that are already existing in on the ground two things one normal human desire to improve your lives that
  209. desire is very much a has a role in this because without that they wouldn't use the phone that's one. Okay. The other is
  210. there is entrepreneurial energy. Both of these are often squandered if these tools are not found.
  211. with the tools both can be unleashed. I I want to I want to turn our attention to those young people who are in
  212. developing economies. We're taking very much the perspective here we are saying in the United States talking about
  213. entrepreneurship in a developing economy. Well, I want to close by by speaking to our audience that's outside
  214. the United States, outside the developed world. What advice would you give to a young entrepreneur who's growing up in
  215. Bangladesh or Pakistan or or my my own example is is itself could be followed. I mean I I mean I'm I'm not trying to
  216. sell myself but what I'm trying to say is that I can I I'm more authority on myself. The point is the point is I got
  217. an education in the west. That's one. Okay. And therefore I was informed. Okay. And I I tried to think clearly of
  218. what is necessary. Okay, that's those are one. But nowadays that is easier than when I try to educate myself. There
  219. was no internet for example. So now you can even sit in Pakistan and learn some of these things. That's one. The other
  220. point is that it's um uh that that you don't you could remember I was saying you need one thing to get to the other
  221. thing. Remember let me show you one aspect of that. the fact that cell phones now exist through my work or
  222. other people's work then that should make their lives a little bit easier and get the information. You can also read
  223. the internet through the smartphone now as an example. So, so you can get lot of
  224. things that didn't exist before, but it's always important to get an education to think clearly and think
  225. about things that might be available in the west that can be adapted in the in the in the lower income countries. But
  226. again there may be other ways of solving problems but this is the one I found to
  227. be um profoundly transformative and also things can hang together around that kind of economic interest dotelling.
  228. Okay. Well thank you so much. It was so interesting and inspiring. Thank you. Thank you very much. Thank you.
  229. [Music]

Brief Summary

Kadir discusses entrepreneurship and innovation in developing economies, focusing on Grameen Phone's impact in Bangladesh.

Key points

  • Kadir's Journey from Bangladesh. Kadir shares his origins and the impact of his childhood experiences on his entrepreneurial journey.
  • The Birth of Grameen Phone. Kadir discusses the challenges he faced in convincing others about his vision for Grameen Phone.
  • The Power of Connectivity. Kadir emphasizes how connectivity can transform economies, especially in developing countries.
  • Breaking Barriers to Innovation. Kadir addresses the practical barriers to entrepreneurial innovation in developing economies.
  • Bangladesh's Economic Impact. Bangladesh is now providing more aid to Norway through dividends than the other way around.
  • The Role of Greed in Entrepreneurship. Exploring how pure greed can lead to valuable economic opportunities.

Episode highlights

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes