New Rules for a New Age: Kevin Werbach Sees Challenges for the FCC

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

Wharton legal studies and business ethics professor Kevin Werbach recently worked with the Obama administration's transition team on a review of the Federal Communications Commission and related technology and telecommunications issues. In an interview with Knowledge@Wharton, he says that advances in technology and the urgent need to restart the economy require the commission to rethink its role -- not just as a regulator, but as an agency that creates jobs and encourages investment. Read the transcript: http://knowledge.wharton.upenn.edu/article.cfm?articleid=2197 📂 Leadership

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. let's talk first if we may about your experience on the transition team what exactly was your role I was co-leading
  2. the agency review of the Federal Communications Commission so there were teams on the transition assigned to
  3. every part of the federal government and our responsibility was to go into the agency meet with the senior staff meet
  4. with outside groups industry public interest groups other interested parties and really roll up our sleeves and
  5. assess what was happening at the agency and try to lay the groundwork for the new administration coming in to put into
  6. place both their people and a new policy agenda now what was your takeaway about
  7. the regarding the agency well the FCC under Kevin Martin who was the chairman at the end of the Bush administration
  8. was was really devastated it was it was a place that had been heavily politicized the staff were demoralized
  9. it was failing in a lot of ways to achieve the kind of benefits that it should be achieving and so we found a
  10. lot of dissatisfaction both inside and outside the government with just the kinds of processes the agency was using
  11. people would say that they're just not being fair they're not being consistent they're not being transparent we really
  12. don't feel like they they have the interest of the American people at heart and so we were really trying to to
  13. ascertain how to revitalize this agency how to take this agency and make it once
  14. again one that could really deliver benefits to the American people that sounds like what a rebuilding job they
  15. weave have one nomination for the Chairman and some other positions that are still open on the Commission itself
  16. is how urgent is it that we get those positions filled quickly oh I think it's very urgent it's it's it's urgent of
  17. course more generally that the president's nominees get confirmed and that and that the additional openings
  18. are filled the FCC is pretty important it oversees a huge swath of the economy the whole telecommunications and media
  19. sector as well as the whole technology sector which is really I think pretty critical to an economic recovery mm-hmm
  20. indeed the it would seem that as to the degree that the work of the FCC can be tied to the economic
  21. recovery will determine the speed with which it gets the attention it needs what how important is the role of the of
  22. the telecommunications and technology generally in the recovery do you think it's extremely important the FCC really
  23. needs to think about itself as an economic stimulus agency as an agency that's about creating jobs and fostering
  24. investment and you look at the telecommunications and media and technology sectors there's a tremendous
  25. opportunity for growth these are not industries that are going down these are industries that in many ways are growing
  26. and they're the foundation for other kinds of new jobs so revitalizing healthcare a central part of that is
  27. computerizing medical records and putting healthcare online that requires broadband out to every part of the
  28. country green energy again requires smart grids instrumenting the electrical grid on broadband networks education
  29. requires the ability to deliver information throughout the country over networks to people so the areas that the
  30. FCC is responsible for can really be central to the recovery are you confident that the Obama administration
  31. recognizes that oh absolutely they recognize that Julius Genachowski has been nominated to be the head of the FCC
  32. has tremendous experience as a business leader and an investor as well as in government and I know he recognizes that
  33. absolutely okay now you're going to be addressing some of the challenges for communications regulation in the coming
  34. years at a seminar tomorrow and I wonder you you're saying in this seminar that the communications networks are the
  35. foundation on which the future of business business of news business interaction entertainment healthcare
  36. education energy conservation and a lot of other economics fact sectors will be built and that the network
  37. infrastructure is the dividing line between the old physical economy of scarcity and the new information economy
  38. of abundance tell us what you mean by these these two terms of the physical economy of scarcity and the information
  39. economy of abundance well it's pretty simple you make things there's a necessary scarcity GM can only put out
  40. so many cars and it costs a certain amount of resources to build each one but bits are bits and they're infinitely
  41. replicable so Google doesn't have the same kind of physical limitations on how many searches it can do or what it can
  42. do with the information that goes into its system now underneath that there are physical networks there's equipment they
  43. have to buy routers and servers and they have to buy telecommunications lines to
  44. connect them up which is why I talked about that being the dividing line but once you have that investment to build
  45. on top of it and to build new services and to scale them out is really limited only by the imagination I see so you're
  46. also suggesting that the biggest challenge for communication is law right now is to take the lessons that we've
  47. learned from some of these virtual ecosystems that live on top of this infrastructure and apply them to the
  48. infrastructure tell us how that works well so so my research really looks at the intersection between law business
  49. and policy around technology and we have 70 plus years of communications regulation in the United States that was
  50. designed for traditional networks for the telephone system for example or broadcast television and radio and
  51. increasingly all those are going online they're all merging in with the internet
  52. all those those silos of networks are converging and we don't have a regulatory structure for that new
  53. converged broadband internet infrastructure partly because justifiably the FCC and other parts of
  54. the government were hesitant to regulate those new services as they were growing
  55. they didn't want to apply the old rules to the new technology which which I was involved with when I was in government
  56. in the 1990s and fully support but at some point you need to have a system that looks at how to ensure networks are
  57. used in the public interest how to ensure that that markets don't go off the rails which is what we saw with the
  58. financial sector for example and we've seen in the past with the telecom sector and that means you need to figure out
  59. the intersection of the legal structure with the new technology with with what the market looks like today right and it
  60. seems that what you're suggesting is that the default setting in addressing regulation of the infrastructure is open
  61. access and by open access you mean so open access means that networks can interconnect for your league so what
  62. makes the Internet the internet people think the Internet is a network it's really not the Internet's a network of
  63. networks so any system that speaks the language of standards that connects into the Internet can be part of this
  64. ecosystem and that's a principle that's allowed the internet to grow and foster so much innovation if we have open
  65. interconnection open access so any broadband network system can be plugged into you can you can attach new services
  66. new devices new applications to that Network then there's a lot more potential for growth so for example we
  67. have a stimulus package now that's going to put seven billion dollars into rural
  68. broadband and and broadband infrastructure to expand out the system that we have in this country if that
  69. only serves the companies that provide that network the value is limited but if it's an open access network that allows
  70. other companies governmental institutions citizen groups to come in and leverage that infrastructure stick a
  71. wireless network on the end create a healthcare application in a rural community and so forth and that
  72. magnifies the value of the network and are there any regulations now that stand in the way of those kinds of structures
  73. being added to the broadband network that comes into these rural areas well that's that's that's the point of this
  74. this research I've been doing it's a total regulatory gray area because the rules we have applied to traditional
  75. telecommunications networks the FCC in the past has said broadband access networks are not what are called
  76. regulated telecommunication services there's something else called information services right which there
  77. are no rules for information services under the existing statutes and so what I'm trying to do in my work is is map
  78. out what those rules should be by reference to some of the enduring principles that are in the
  79. Communications Act already the Obama administration has received some degree of attention for its consciousness of a
  80. lot of these services that you're talking about President Obama was very worried about losing his blackberry for
  81. example do you think that that orientation is going to have a big impact on the kinds of policies
  82. that we see emerge from the FCC in and other related agencies oh I think it's going to have a big impact across the
  83. government but but think about work today in any kind of organization there are very few organizations today that
  84. don't use email say and they don't use the internet as just a fundamental part of how they do business how they manage
  85. their supply chain and so forth so governments the same thing and if you have people in government who are not
  86. familiar with those technologies that the average worker today the average manager takes for granted there's going
  87. to be a disconnect in their ability to develop policies that reflect even today's economy let alone tomorrow's so
  88. I think the fact that there are so many people involved in this administration who really are technology savvy and who
  89. get it just at a personal level is important the other thing is these technologies are incredibly powerful
  90. well I remember on the transition talking with someone who had been involved in the Clinton transition in
  91. 1992 and later was a senior official in the Commerce Department and he said back
  92. then they had to walk around with disks so when people would write memos or try and group collaborate on a policy
  93. recommendation they would literally have to walk around with floppy disks across
  94. the office and of course today we can do that all online we had a collaboration system that we could use for doing the
  95. work of the transition and just for the transition process which is a limited time it's just 77 days which has to do a
  96. tremendous amount the ability to use that technology was very powerful I see and and those powerful technologies
  97. you're talking about right now a lot of attention is being paid to handheld instruments that really behave more like
  98. personal computers and then then telephones and everybody seems to be that's the big technology of the moment
  99. it's very difficult to look far down the road for these things but what are some
  100. of the other new technologies that you think that the FCC is going to have to address in this come in the next four
  101. years say so we're still just getting a taste of mobile we're now in a world with about three and a half billion
  102. people having mobile phones which is more than double the number of people who have wireline phones and that
  103. transition is happening and we're just starting on the smartphone revolution so the iphone is really
  104. symbolic of this transition you mentioned from phones to handheld computing devices I talked to a friend
  105. yesterday who's saying he was at Samsung Samsung is introducing 20 iPhone like devices next year 20 of them for just
  106. one company so that revolution is going to be quite significant I think we're also going to see group collaboration
  107. mechanisms some of the things i talked about becoming more powerful in the workplace as well as the ability to use
  108. video much more integrate that and other kinds of media integrated into the process also just just the ability to
  109. take search technology which of course is very wide spirit on the internet and and apply it much more more directly
  110. into lots of other services we've already seen social media interfere or make its presence known i should say in
  111. realm of the law where for instance a trial in philadelphia in which a juror was sharing observations via twitter do
  112. you see that as a something that's going to be happening more and more as these ads these appellees social networking
  113. applications become more widely adopted people sharing all kinds of information is that going to be something that is
  114. going to be looked at by regulators do you think well as first of all I certainly think that that's something
  115. that's going to be increasingly pervasive and Twitter is your the current symbol of it but it's really
  116. much broader than that and it follows on from the point about mobile devices and
  117. smartphones as you have people more and more densely connected on platforms that
  118. are interconnected and that are converged and then you have much more intelligence both in the devices about
  119. where they are as well as intelligence in things in terms of connecting to the devices through wireless networks and so
  120. forth that leads to the lots more potential for applications and services that leverage off of that connectivity
  121. so Twitter is is one early example I think of what happens when people can communicate all the time about what
  122. they're doing and that can be aggregated together from a regulatory standpoint sure they're there are a whole set of
  123. issue is that government is just starting to wrestle with privacy is one that's that's extremely important but deeply
  124. misunderstood it's not an either or question of whether I'm public or private we're going to be sharing things
  125. all the time and people's preferences are going to be changing based on what circumstances they're in we're in a
  126. world and increasingly in a world where everything is connected so regulators and government as well as individuals
  127. need to wrestle with what are appropriate limits in terms of sharing information see well thank you very much
  128. for being with us today and we look forward to your seminar tomorrow my pleasure
  129. Oh

Brief Summary

The episode covers FCC's role in economic recovery and regulatory challenges in telecommunications and technology sectors.

Key points

  • Revitalizing the FCC. The FCC is in dire need of revitalization to serve the American people effectively.
  • Importance of Telecommunications. Telecommunications is critical for economic recovery and job creation.
  • The Future of Communication. The transition to mobile and smart devices is reshaping communication and regulation.

Tension

45/ 100Some tension

Related episodes