Nvidia's Leadership Crisis Reveals a Bigger Problem

Knowledge at Wharton

Ask about Knowledge at Wharton

Episode Description

ABOUT THE EPISODE Nvidia's leadership turmoil raises a bigger question: Can a company built around one extraordinary leader survive without them?

Henning Piezunka, Wharton Associate Professor of Management, examines the challenges of CEO succession planning and what companies can learn from the leadership transitions at Apple, Disney, and other major organizations.

From the power of corporate boards to the difficulty of grooming future CEOs, this conversation explores what makes companies resilient enough to survive beyond their founders.

ABOUT THE PODCAST This Week in Business features interviews with Wharton faculty about the latest news, fascinating trends, and issues impacting both consumers and the business world. Episodes are recorded at the Wharton School and published twice per week.

----- The Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania is committed to sharing its intellectual capital through Knowledge at Wharton, the school’s online business analysis journal.

Launched in 1999, Knowledge at Wharton offers free access to:

- Articles, podcasts, and videos highlighting Wharton faculty research and analysis of current business trends - Interviews with book authors from Wharton School Press - In-depth series of curated content like Wharton Executive Education’s Nano Tools for Leaders - A searchable database of more than 10,000 articles covering all aspects of business - A weekly newsletter that delivers Knowledge at Wharton insights directly to your inbox

Visit the Knowledge at Wharton homepage: https://whr.tn/3qUpSBE Subscribe to the Knowledge at Wharton YouTube channel: https://whr.tn/3DEAgAU

Read the full transcriptHide the full transcript
  1. Well, by now, many of you who follow the world of artificial intelligence know that Jensen Wang,
  2. the co-founder and formerly CEO of NVIDIA, is no longer with that company because
  3. of what occurred in his personal life. But what does it tell us about the world of AI,
  4. but also the world of corporate structure? Pleasure to be joined by Wharton professor
  5. Henning Piezunka to talk about this. Henning, great to catch up with you again. How are you, sir?
  6. Great to see you, Dan. Good to have me. Obviously, a lot that we can discuss, but what jumps to mind for you in terms of
  7. how this has all transpired in terms of the corporate side of it, but also the business
  8. side of this? You know, I appreciate everything you say, but let me kind of take issue with how
  9. you kind of opened this up. Not everybody who cares about AI, everybody knows what happened
  10. with Jensen Wang, not just people who care about AI. You know, like, think about it, like a trillion
  11. dollar of stock market value has been wiped out, right? But probably nobody has ever paid more for
  12. sex, right? This is just incredible what has just kind of happened. Yeah, you see, like, look,
  13. from the perspective of like, you see, like, from a management perspective, I think what this really
  14. kind of shows is the organizational structure at NVIDIA was obviously kind of too focused on him,
  15. probably, right? You see, like, the reason why they are hit so hard is that he has played such
  16. a central role, right? And you see, he was actually kind of talking about this, like, oh, I have 60,
  17. 70 direct reports and things like this, and this can function excellently well, it can enormously
  18. well. But at the same time, right, now the organization kind of is missing this kind of
  19. binding part, which kind of ties it all together. So it really made me wonder about how could you
  20. have rendered this company more resilient against events such as that. Okay, so how do you do that?
  21. Because I think the other question on this is, this was a startup at one point. We talk about
  22. him being a co-founder. Is the reliance that was there on Jensen Wang a trait of what we see play
  23. out with startups in general? You see, in a certain way, in some aspects, NVIDIA is actually better on
  24. this than others, right? Part of the reason why he's not CEO anymore now is that he doesn't have
  25. like all that many A and B shares and stuff like this. So the board has actually an enormous power
  26. and can actually influence the situation quite tremendously. This is quite different in other
  27. kind of companies such as Alphabet and Metar and so on, right? So you remember, obviously, right,
  28. like Apple kind of fired Steve Jobs from its own company, somewhat of a similar situation in the
  29. sense of that he didn't have that much power in the company, right? So that the board actually
  30. had this kind of power. And we've seen other kinds of incidents like this, obviously, Sam Altman at
  31. OpenAI come to light. So this is in many ways, like really a power play, right? Like who has how
  32. much power? But then there's another aspect, which I think is what we just pointed out, right? It's
  33. like, okay, to what degree should the organization be dependent on a single individual, right? And
  34. you see, going back to the Steve Jobs analogy, he always said like, look, his biggest accomplishment
  35. in his life is Apple. It's not the iPod. It's not the MacBook, right? But it's Apple. And so the
  36. question, and this is now up to be seen, whether Nvidia has kind of grown as an organization,
  37. which really functions without him. I very much hope it does. I hope for my stock portfolio that
  38. it does. I hope for the world that it does. But we'll see. The jury's out there.
  39. The value, as you kind of alluded to, the portfolios of many people going down significantly on this because of how Nvidia had shot up so much in the last few years,
  40. from a business perspective, this quite a big loss for the company in terms of its value
  41. by not having him kind of leading the ship moving forward. I can nothing but agree with this. Yes, a lot of kind of stock market value has been lost. But you
  42. see, a lot of stock market value has been has been gained, right? You kind of you join on the
  43. way up and then you also join on the way down. Right. So we have kind of all benefited from this.
  44. You see, it would have been lovely that if this would have not happened, or if an organization
  45. would be in place where if this has happened, right, we would kind of just quickly move on.
  46. In certain way, you can actually say like, look, in many ways, there has been misbehavior and
  47. there has been personal accountability at this point. And so you can also see this as like an
  48. upside to a certain degree. Right. So I we are now kind of figuring out, OK, we wish the misbehavior
  49. would not have happened, but it's a little bit unclear how. It's not necessarily that you see
  50. some people have said, like, you should have stayed. Some people, this would have been like a
  51. complete HR disaster. This is a decision. This is a decision with enormous tradeoffs.
  52. Now we have to see how we deal with the scenario. Let me ask you about the the question of
  53. succession. You see how companies in many cases, when a CEO is maybe a year or two years out from
  54. leaving the company, they start to groom that next person to take over that role.
  55. This is obviously not that situation. But should we assume that there was some sort of succession
  56. plan in case something happened to Jensen Wong if by, you know, he had gotten into an accident and
  57. died in a car wreck or a plane wreck or something like that, that there was some sort of
  58. succession plan in place? You know, first of all, let me say like, look, succession is not on TV
  59. anymore, but here we have everything right. We have Chinese spies. We have sex. We have kind of
  60. stock market crashes. So this feels like kind of being made by HBO. So in. You see, it's hard to say
  61. from the outside to what degree the board had a succession plan in place. The fact that they've
  62. now called for an interim CEO, right, where they have been explicit that this is an interim CEO,
  63. suggests that they did not have like a lot of people where they say like, oh, we have groomed
  64. this successor and groomed this successor. Now, this is obviously challenging, right? The more
  65. you have like a larger than life figure than Jensen Wong, right? And we can think of other cases,
  66. right? We can think of like Howard Schultz and Starbucks or so, right? Very often, you see,
  67. it's very difficult to kind of step into these footsteps and not just to step into these footsteps,
  68. but actually to groom someone to that level, right? Like how do you actually kind of
  69. gain authority? How do you actually kind of gain influence within the organization?
  70. If somebody like that is still around, this is not to say that this cannot be done,
  71. right? It worked fantastically well with Tim Cook. Now, an advantage, right, of the illness
  72. of Steve Jobs was that they actually had time to kind of, that Tim Cook had time to grow
  73. internally, time to grow externally into this kind of role. Right now, the impression is there
  74. is nobody who they've kind of groomed to that stage or where it's evident that this person can
  75. take over. There's a debate about external candidates. We'll see soon. Well, and I guess
  76. the term of succession, it's not one that always works out. You think of the case of Disney
  77. with Bob Iger. He retired the first time. They brought in a new CEO. It did not work out. He
  78. came back. Then they groomed somebody else and seemingly it has worked out to this point. So,
  79. it's not a 100% foolproof entity here. Dan, you're absolutely right. Wharton has just published
  80. a new working paper on succession. You can simply search for it. People are also welcome to connect
  81. with me on LinkedIn or to write me an email. I'm happy to send this to them. Succession has actually
  82. been like a major focus for Wharton recently. It's something we're really pushing. And for exactly
  83. the same reason you're pointing out. You see, this can't go right. It really can't go right,
  84. but it often doesn't. Very often because organizations or boards are not prepared.
  85. And you know what? I give them credit for that, for not being prepared. Because here's the thing
  86. about succession. In an ideal world, the succession is a very rare event. If you have a lot of exercise
  87. in managing successions, it's not a good thing. So, a succession is really supposed to be a rare
  88. event. So, you see, for lots of things in life, we say, get your daily reps in. Please don't get
  89. in your daily reps for successions. Hopefully, you don't have that many. But then at the same time,
  90. it's very difficult to be constantly to say, the moment it happens, I am prepared.
  91. But this is in part what boards need to do. I'm happy to send people the working paper.
  92. Don't hesitate to kind of reach out. And great to talk to you again. Thanks very much for your
  93. time and jumping on and discussing this topic so quickly. Thanks for having me. I look forward
  94. to see how this plays out. Thank you. Henning Piezunka of the Wharton School.

Brief Summary

Henning Piezunka explains why Nvidia’s reliance on Jensen Huang raises urgent questions about board power, CEO succession, and corporate resilience.

Key points

  • A company built around one person. The guest argues that Nvidia’s organizational structure was too focused on Jensen Wang, leaving the company without a clear “binding part” when he was gone.
  • Who holds the power?. The conversation connects leadership transitions at Nvidia, Apple, and OpenAI to the influence of boards and the power held by individual leaders.
  • Can Nvidia thrive without its leader?. The guest hopes Nvidia has grown into an organization that can function without its central figure, but says the outcome is still uncertain.
  • Succession is hard to rehearse. Companies need to prepare for leadership transitions, even though succession should be rare and boards may struggle to be ready when it happens.

Tension

24/ 100Calm

Related episodes